Central Hawke’s Bay District Council decides to push for Burnside Bridge repair

Central Hawke’s Bay District Council has decided to spend $100,000 to test whether repairing Burnside Bridge near Takapau is feasible and affordable.
The decision was voted on at a council meeting on Wednesday, with six councillors in favour and three against.
The Takapau community has pushed hard for alternative repair or replacement options to be explored after being told during consultation that a replacement bridge was economically unviable.
The one-lane bridge over Makaretu River was smashed by floodwaters and debris during Cyclone Gabrielle and closed due to structural damage to the piers and two adjoining bridge spans.
Locals were told a two-lane replacement would cost up to $16 million, with the estimate for a one-lane bridge at $9m.
Previous funding applications to NZTA for a replacement bridge and lower-cost ford crossing were unsuccessful due to what NZTA said were the high cost, low traffic volumes of the bridge and the availability of an alternative route.
An agenda for the council meeting on Wednesday notes a targeted repair of the 100m bridge, built in 1921, could be done for an estimated $1.6m.
The agenda said the repair would be to 25% of the existing structure. It was expected to provide a 20-40-year service life with routine bridge maintenance, subject to investigation, design, consents, procurement and funding approval.
Wednesday’s decision authorises the council’s chief executive to progress technical investigations, economic assessment, and engagement with NZTA. The decision does not commit the council to repairing the bridge.
Councillors Brent Muggeridge, Kirsty Lawrence and Pip Burne voted against it.
Muggeridge said he didn’t accept it was a good use of money.
“We are not here to make decisions on sentiment; we are here to make them on the best outcome for the ratepayer of CHB, not just one community, and I just can’t see this $100,000 being a good spend.”
Councillor Todd Chote said he was in favour of the option, but felt consideration should be given to asking the community affected by the bridge to pay more of the $100,000.
He asked whether a targeted rate for Takapau and the surrounding area could help fund the bridge repairs.
“I love their heart and their passion they have got into this; are they willing to back that up?”
The council’s chief financial officer, Brent Chamberlain, told the meeting it was possible, but it would require community consultation and backing.
Councillor Gerard Minehan said the council owed it to the community to explore further.
“They have worked tirelessly to explore every possible solution, and I believe we owe it to them to ensure every reasonable option is properly investigated before making a final decision.
“For me it isn’t just about the financial cost; councillors have previously recognised the importance of investing in projects that have strong community support.”
Deputy mayor Jerry Greer echoed the sentiment and said no stone should be left unturned.
In July, a petition of over 350 signatures led by Takapau local Shelley Burne-Field was presented to the council alongside letters of support.
The petition requested that all options and funding be explored by local and central governing bodies to rebuild, repair or replace the Burnside Bridge to a standard and cost acceptable to the community.
Earlier, Central Hawke’s Bay farmer Dave Ellison sought his own estimate to rebuild the bridge from North Island bridge construction company Bridge It NZ after being told it was unviable.
The council agenda noted this estimate had since been withdrawn by Bridge It NZ’s company director due to it being inaccurate.
Michaela Gower joined Hawke’s Bay Today in 2023 and is based out of the Hastings newsroom. She covers Dannevirke and Hawke’s Bay news and loves sharing stories about farming and rural communities.
