Auckland man who fractured baby’s skull and caused bilateral haemorrhage jailed

An Auckland man who fractured a 5-month-old baby’s skull, caused a bilateral haemorrhage and split the child’s frenulum has been jailed.
Immediately after the abuse, the infant was bleeding from the nose and mouth but the man was “reluctant” to take the child to the hospital.
Waitākere District Court Judge Ophir Cassidy said at his sentencing on Thursday that Aotearoa was in “crisis” due to this kind of abuse.
The defendant’s lawyer, Daniel Perić, argued his client should be granted permanent name suppression, saying there was “nothing to be gained” by identifying him.
Perić said allowing media to name the offender risked turning this “misery” into a “public spectacle”.
“I’ll stop you there Mr Perić,” Judge Cassidy said, before stating that the offending was against someone who was among New Zealand’s most vulnerable.
“In this particular case, a child, but more so a 5-month-old baby.”
Police prosecutor Natasja Morris said name suppression would not be appropriate, adding that it was in the public interest for the man’s application for anonymity to be declined.
“The victim is a 5-month-old with serious injuries.
“Name suppression should not be granted.”
Explanation ‘not consistent’ with injuries
The man claimed the injuries were caused when he fell while holding the baby, Judge Cassidy said.
“I don’t accept your explanation.
“The child has no voice. I can’t hear from the child to tell me why [their] front frenulum was split and why [they] suffered a fractured skull.
“This is offending where a vulnerable baby has ended up with injuries that are not consistent with the explanation given.”
Perić submitted that there was never a question about whether his client was responsible for causing the injuries: “The mechanism was the only aspect in the case under scrutiny.”
Judge Cassidy began the final part of the sentencing with a whakataukī (Māori proverb) pointing to the importance of children, who were vulnerable and deserved special protection.
“You have pleaded guilty to a charge of wounding with reckless disregard. The charge carrying a maximum of seven years’ imprisonment.”
She said the man accepted the summary of facts, which included that the baby was bleeding from the mouth and nose, and that the defendant was “reluctant” to take the child to the hospital.
Judge Cassidy granted the man discounts because he participated in restorative justice, undertook a course, pleaded guilty and had personal factors that warranted a sentence reduction.
“Hurt people, hurt people,” the judge said.
She said the man had a history of violence and non-compliance with his bail.
“There were breaches of bail, five which he accepted ... Clear breaches of bail that allowed the child to be having contact with your client.”
She set a starting point of 36 months’ imprisonment and after a 35% reduction, Judge Cassidy issued an end sentence of two years’ imprisonment.
Judge Cassidy declined the man’s name suppression application but on his request, Perić was granted 20 working days so his client could consider an appeal.
Katie Harris is an Auckland-based journalist who covers issues such as sexual assault, workplace misconduct, media, crime and justice. She joined the Herald in 2020.
Sign up to The Daily H, a free newsletter curated by our editors and delivered straight to your inbox every weekday.
