Walking, bus, scooter or ferry: Which Auckland commute is cheapest?

Reporter Mitchell Hageman rides an electric scooter to work. Photo / Cameron Pitney
Can you cut costs and increase convenience when your commute is on the other side of Auckland? Mitchell Hageman finds alternative ways to get to work without using the car.

As the cost of fuel rises, many Kiwis are looking for alternative ways to commute to work. Mitchell Hageman tests some different options to see if they save on time, money and comfort.

The average Kiwi spends more than eight days per year sitting in their car, according to a Global Auto Trader study, which is not ideal when fuel prices are soaring and the cost of living is high.

It’s not quite “out in the wops”, but the average commute from my flat in Torbay to the Herald’s Auckland CBD offices takes about 45 minutes by car – a gas-guzzling Hyundai Veloster Turbo.

A quick punch into an online fuel calculator determines the trip uses 1.4litres of fuel, which amounts to a fuel cost of $4.77 one way.

To help my bank account and the impact my commute has on my free time, I sought out some alternative ways to get to work for a week. From scooters to shared rides, here’s what I found.

Travelling in an Uber Pool brought comfort but not convenience.
Travelling in an Uber Pool brought comfort but not convenience.

Day 1: Uber Pool

Cost or time-effective aren’t words I’d use to describe my first experience with Uber Pool. After trying in vain to find a carpooling option through social media and my neighbours (who all worked in different directions), I opted to see how Uber’s carpool service would fare.

The inconvenience started when I waited 14 minutes for the ride to even register, and then another 15 minutes for the driver to get to me. As we snailed through traffic, the driver informed me we were going to Beach Rd near Takapuna to pick up our second passenger. We dropped them off in Wairau, getting stuck in traffic to get on the motorway before heading to the city for my drop-off.

Despite how long it took, there were some positives. It was quiet, which allowed me to do a bit of work on my laptop in the air-conditioned space. I also got dropped right at the door, avoiding the sprinkling of rain that had just hit the CBD.

For short-distance trips when time isn’t a factor, this could be a game-changer. But I wouldn’t rely on this for your daily commute, as it will cost you time and money. If you want to carpool, scrounge around for that neighbour or mate who can pick you up on the way and give them a couple of dollars instead.

Cost: $47.04 (saved $7.82 from normal Uber)

Saving: Nothing.This ride was $42.27 more expensive than my usual solo drive in

Commute time: 75 minutes

Ease of use: 4/5

Verdict: Great for short trips, but not for the long haul

Day 2: Walking

Exercise gear on, I laced up my trainers and began the 6.4km walk to the closest bus hub (Albany Station) that would get me over the bridge (and save me a few dollars). Google Maps said it would take me just under an hour and a half, but I knew if I picked up the pace, I’d be able to beat that.

It was a brisk, clear morning and my biggest fear was making it up Deep Creek Rd, a notoriously steep hill. Despite plenty of people zooming past me on electric scooters, I made it up in good time and without having a cardiac episode.

Making it to the station about an hour after leaving home, my legs were glad to meet the bus seat, and my body was thankful for the workout.

Cost: $3.00 (bus fare)

Saving: $1.77

Commute time: 80 minutes (60-minute walk, 20 minutes on the bus)

Ease of use: 3/5

Verdict: Good if you want the exercise and aren’t stressed about time. Not good if it’s raining ...

A ferry ride was fun, but not time-effective for Mitchell Hageman.
A ferry ride was fun, but not time-effective for Mitchell Hageman.

Day 3: Ferry

As it bucketed down with rain, I trudged towards the first of FOUR bus rides that would get me to the Birkenhead Ferry Terminal. I first travelled to Albany, then on to Smales Farm, and then halfway up Glenfield Rd, where I walked two minutes to get my final ride to the ferry terminal.

Being the only bus passenger heading to the terminal, I got chatting to the driver about my experiment. Like the rest of us, he was feeling the pinch, talking about tax rates and gas prices when it came to the buses.

It was already 9.30am by this point (I had been travelling for an hour and 15 minutes), and I now had to wait another 15 minutes for the ferry. At $12 one way, this trip was turning into an expensive option. The boat journey itself was quick and pleasant (albeit a little choppy), with a brief stop at Northcote before landing at the Downtown terminal just after 10am. From there, it was a quick walk to our Graham St offices, and I arrived at work about two hours after leaving home.

Unless you live close to a ferry terminal, you’re not going to save money travelling by boat, and for me, it was a waste of time. If I were a leisurely traveller wanting an explorative day out, perhaps it would be a different story.

Cost: $16.50 (bus and ferry fare)

Saving: Nothing. This trip was $11.73 more expensive than driving my car

Commute time: 2 hours

Ease of use: 2/5

Verdict: Good for a day out, not a commute

Reporter Mitchell Hageman rides a scooter to work. Photo / Cameron Pitney
Reporter Mitchell Hageman rides a scooter to work. Photo / Cameron Pitney

Day 4: Electric scooter

Because the sun was shining (for once), it was time to test my balance and borrow my flatmate’s electric scooter for the day. It is a beast. It has wheels that look like they’d be sturdy enough to support a tank.

After a couple of test runs the night before, and with my high-vis gear and helmet on, I was steady on my feet and ready to go. But with the undulating run I had towards the Albany bus station, it was clear I wasn’t going to be going top speed. I evened out to a brisk 30km/h, staying largely on footpaths but veering on to the road to avoid any pedestrians.

I made it into the office in great time, only 15 minutes after I would usually get in. Yes, at approximately 30kg, the scooter was a bit hard to lug up the stairs and on to the bus , but getting the fresh air was great. If I lived within 10 minutes of work, it would be an absolute life-saver.

Cost: $3.00 (Bus fare)

Saving: $1.77 with the bus fare. The scooter retails at over $2000, so it’s quite an investment

Commute time: 1 hour

Ease of use: 4.5/5

Verdict: A game-changer if I lived closer to work

The Auckland Transport buses in action.
The Auckland Transport buses in action.

Day 5: Bus

As someone who has lived on the tail end of the North Shore for a few years now, for me a bus has been the only effective mode of public transport to get to the city. Yes, heading in from Torbay is a long trek, and I have partly used the bus to get over the bridge most days of this experiment, but it turns out the full route from my house to work might be the second-best thing to driving.

The Auckland Transport app was precise, giving up-to-date tracking of my bus, as well as exactly how much my journey would cost. My first bus to Albany Station was bang on time, and while a little crowded in the latter stops, there was still enough room. I even managed to check my emails and messages. You can also pay with either payWave or load up an AT Hop card. The price is the same, but there is a $50 seven-day fare cap with the Hop card.

The Northern Express runs every three to five minutes at peak times, so there’s no trouble getting across the bridge, and you also miss all the traffic that you would usually be sitting in if you were behind the wheel. If you can cope with the occasional crowding and odd breakdown, this option is a slam dunk.

Cost: $6.50 (maximum $50 fare cap for seven days if using AT Hop card)

Saving: Nope. This cost $1.73 more than the car

Commute time: 48 minutes

Ease of use: 5/5

Verdict: Easy, relatively reliable and stress-free

Final thoughts:

This experiment gave me a crash course on Auckland’s transport viability and opened my eyes to new ways of travelling. For anyone living within a shorter radius of their city workplace or “over the bridge”, scooter and walking are excellent cost-savers.

If you live close to the ferry, buying a pass would likely save you money and time in the long run if you don’t have to factor in a bus ride.

I don’t think I’ll be giving up the car just yet, but I’m definitely not afraid to keep it in the garage when needed to be a bit kinder to my wallet.

Mitchell Hageman joined the Herald’s entertainment and lifestyle team in 2024. He previously worked as a multimedia journalist for Hawke’s Bay Today.