The worst snacks for your cholesterol (and what to have instead)

Emily Craig
Your snacking habits could be bad for our cholesterol. Photo / Unsplash
Your snacking habits could be bad for our cholesterol. Photo / Unsplash

Your grazing habit doesn’t have to wreak havoc on your heart health, providing you make the right choices.

If you’re over 45, chances are, you have high cholesterol. Dangerous quantities of the waxy, fat-like substance often circulate in the blood of people in this age group, clogging their arteries and pushing up their risk of a heart attack and stroke.

Your snacking habit could be the problem. “The majority of people still have too much sugar and our saturated fat intake is still above the recommendations,” says Dr Thomas Butler, a senior lecturer in nutrition at Edge Hill University, whose research focuses on heart health. “Snacking, in that context, adds more pressure on to an already stressed system.”

Here, he explains exactly how snacking is deleterious for your cholesterol, the snacks to cut out and those to add into your diet.

How even small amounts of food can affect your cholesterol

“Diet is a really big factor that influences cholesterol,” notes Butler, who is part of the medical, scientific and research committee at HeartUK and chairs the British Dietetic Association cardiovascular specialist group.

The biggest contributor is saturated fat, which increases “bad” low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol. This type creates plaque build-up in our arteries and raises the risk of heart disease.

Our livers, which create 80% of the cholesterol in our body, grab on to LDL cholesterol when it passes by the organ, so it can be broken down. However, eating too much saturated fat interferes with this process, allowing for LDL cholesterol to build up in the blood.

Additionally, eating too much sugar triggers spikes in insulin that force the liver to churn out fat that turns into LDL cholesterol, while also lowering “good” high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol.

“A single snack doesn’t have an immediate effect on cholesterol levels – it takes days, if not weeks, to see changes in cholesterol,” Butler explains. “However, what people snack on frequently will have a meaningful impact on changes in cholesterol levels. Certain unhealthy snacks can raise LDL cholesterol and can also bring down HDL, the good cholesterol. Similarly, healthy snacks will have the opposite effect and may help improve cholesterol levels.”

The worst snacks for your cholesterol

1. Sausage rolls

Sausage rolls are high in calories. Photo / 123rf
Sausage rolls are high in calories. Photo / 123rf

A typical sausage roll contains 11g of saturated fat (55% of an adult’s recommended daily limit) and zero fibre (when adults should be hitting 30g per day).

“Saturated fats push up LDL cholesterol,” he explains. “With sausage rolls, you have the saturated fat in the pastry and the meat, so it’s a double hit. They are also devoid of fibre, which is important for flushing LDL cholesterol from our body.”

The savoury snack is also high in calories (around 350), so it can contribute to weight gain. “Fat is the most calorific macronutrient, so the more fat in a food, the more calories,” Butler says. “Excess saturated fat in our diet worsens cholesterol metabolism, increasing LDL cholesterol and reducing HDL cholesterol.”

Shop-bought sausage rolls are also an ultra-processed food (UPF), meaning they contain ingredients such as preservatives and stabilisers. Research suggests that a higher UPF may nudge the liver to release more cholesterol.

“Sausage rolls are also quite salty,” he notes, typically containing 1.5g (25% of an adult’s daily limit). Too much salt can increase blood pressure, which, like high cholesterol, damages heart and blood vessels.

Tip: “If you’re wedded to eating sausage rolls, try swapping to a smaller one,” Butler says. You could also try having it alongside baked beans. This will reduce the amount of saturated fat the snack contains and increase the fibre.

2. Danish pastries

“Pastries you might buy with your morning coffee, like a Danish or other baked good, will be high in butter and might have palm fats,” Butler notes. “Both of those ingredients are high in saturated fats, while the pastry offers very little fibre, so it’s similar to a sausage roll but with less salt.”

A typical Danish contains around 9g of saturated fat, 350 calories and just 2.5g of fibre. “The issue with sweet baked goods is that of course they also contain sugar,” he notes. A single Danish can contain 30g of added sugar (an adult’s entire daily limit). Excess sugar can overwhelm the liver, causing it to convert sugar into bad cholesterol, while lowering good cholesterol.

“Foods that are both fatty and sweet aren’t good from a cholesterol point of view,” Butler confirms.

Tip: “Go for a fruit toast instead,” he recommends. “It tends to be lower in calories, sugar and saturated fat, but can still contain a lot of sugar. That said, if you have a healthy diet – with plenty of vegetables, fruit, oily fish and lean meat – having a Danish pastry as an occasional treat is not a problem.”

3. Chocolate biscuits

If you’re frequently snacking on biscuits, reflect on why, says Dr Butler. Photo / 123rf
If you’re frequently snacking on biscuits, reflect on why, says Dr Butler. Photo / 123rf

“Chocolate biscuits aren’t particularly good for saturated fat but also from a sugar perspective,” so can contribute to high cholesterol, Butler says.

Each chocolate digestive, for example, contains 83 calories, 2.1g saturated fat and 4.8g of sugar. “Going for an oat-based chocolate biscuit isn’t a fix,” he notes. While oats are heart-friendly, these biscuits contain more calories (93), saturated fat (2.2g) and sugar (6.1g) than a digestive.

Tip: The next time you’re hankering for a biscuit, Butler recommends a Light Rich Tea, which contains just 38 calories, 0.1g of saturated fat and 1.1g of sugar. “They taste, in my opinion, just the same as a standard Rich Tea.” However, if you’re frequently snacking on biscuits, “reflect on why”, he suggests. “There’s a psychological reason why we want to eat something, it can be because we’re stressed or bored.”

4. Ice cream

“Ice cream contains a lot of added sugar and we know really high intakes of free sugar can affect the triglycerides in our blood,” Butler says. Sugar can increase triglycerides, which are a type of fat that behaves like LDL, while also lowering HDL, he explains. Two scoops of ice cream contain around 200 calories, 17g of sugar and 10g of saturated fat.

Tip: “When it comes to ice cream, watch your portion size,” he recommends. A healthier swap would be a low-fat frozen yoghurt, as it will be lower in calories and reduce your saturated fat intake.

The best snacks for your cholesterol

1. Unsalted nuts

Snacking on unsalted nuts is an evidence-backed way to lower your cholesterol. “The majority are low in saturated fats and high in unsaturated fats, which is good for cholesterol,” Butler notes.

They also contain fibre (up to 4g per serving), as well as small amounts of compounds called stanols and sterols, all of which stop the body from absorbing as much cholesterol. “With a portion of nuts per day, you might be looking at a 3% reduction in LDL within a few weeks,” he says.

Tip: “While peanuts count, walnuts, almonds, Brazil nuts and hazelnuts have the most benefits,” Butler says. However, it’s worth noting that the recommended portion size is 30g. While healthy, nuts are high in calories, so it can be helpful to measure out a serving and avoid eating from the packet.

2. Oat cakes

“Oat cakes contain beta-glucan, which is a type of fibre that slows down the way the body absorbs cholesterol from the gut,” Butler notes. In the gut, beta-glucan forms a gel that sweeps up cholesterol-rich bile acids.

“You need about 3g of beta-glucan per day to lower LDL cholesterol by roughly 5%,” he explains. “Depending on the brand, three oat cakes provides about 1g of beta glucan. Coupled with a breakfast of 40g of porridge oats, you’d hit your 3g. So that’s a good little snack to have.”

Tip: “If you want to add a topping to your oat cake, you could use a cholesterol-lowering spread,” he says. “They contain stanols or sterols which reduce cholesterol absorption in the intestine.” Top with black pepper and a squeeze of lemon, he suggests.

3. Edamame beans

Edamame beans are full of fibre, low in saturated fat and rich in soya protein. Photo / 123rf
Edamame beans are full of fibre, low in saturated fat and rich in soya protein. Photo / 123rf

“Legumes, pulses and beans are really effective at lowering cholesterol,” Butler says. “Edamame beans, in particular, are excellent because they are full of fibre, low in saturated fat and rich in soya protein.” Edamame snack pots contain 235 calories and 7.2g of fibre and 17.3g of protein per 120g.

“Soya protein modestly reduces LDL cholesterol,” he confirms. Research shows that 25g of soya protein per day for six weeks – found in edamame beans but also tofu, soya milk and meat substitute products – lowered LDL cholesterol by 3-4%.

Tip: Snacking on edamame beans can form part of the cholesterol-lowering Portfolio Diet, which involves eating 50g of plant protein, such as edamame beans, while also prioritising oats, apples and nuts, he notes. Following the diet has been shown to slash cholesterol by 30% in a month.

4. Low-fat yoghurt

Yoghurt has a neutral effect on cholesterol, research shows. Butler recommends opting for low-fat when snacking, as “it’s just as high in protein and calcium and it’s much lower in calories, while still having the sating effects”. Snacking on food that keeps us full, such as yoghurt, reduces the risk of reaching for biscuits and overeating, he adds.

Tip: Topping your yoghurt with raspberries will have a cholesterol-lowering effect, thanks to their 3g of fibre per 80g serving. “Raspberries have quite a bit of soluble fibre,” he notes. Pectin is the type of soluble fibre in raspberries – as well as apples and oranges – and consuming 6g per day for three weeks has been shown to lower cholesterol.