The hidden health risks in your cup of tea

Ella Nunn
After examining 150 beverages – hot and cold – scientists from the University of Birmingham found that hot tea contained the highest level of microplastics. Photo / 123rf
After examining 150 beverages – hot and cold – scientists from the University of Birmingham found that hot tea contained the highest level of microplastics. Photo / 123rf

Your daily cuppa may expose you to more microplastics than soft drinks or coffee. Here’s what the science says.

English breakfast, Earl Grey, green or chamomile: regardless of your preferred cuppa, your morning brew has a whole host of health benefits, from improving focus and mood to aiding digestion.

It is hard to imagine that tea poses any risks to our health. However, a new study published in Science of the Total Environment challenges this notion. Amid growing concerns around our exposure to microplastics (minuscule fragments of plastic found in everything from clothes to food), scientists from the University of Birmingham put a range of common beverages to the test.

They examined over 150 drinks, both hot and cold, and discovered that hot tea contained the highest level of microplastics.

Scientists are continuing to investigate the dangers of microplastics, with various studies linking them to health issues including inflammation, hormone disruption, and gut problems.

So, is tea really that harmful – and how can we make our morning brew safer and healthier?

Microplastics in our tea bags and takeaway cups

There is some debate over who invented the first tea bag. Its origins have been traced to 1908, when the American tea importer Thomas Sullivan shipped samples of his product in silk pouches. While he did not intend for his customers to put them directly into hot water, some found this a convenient, mess-free way to brew tea.

Over time, tea bags evolved from silk to paper to nylon to bioplastic. While they are certainly a convenient way to make a morning brew, researchers at the University of Birmingham have discovered that tea bags are also a significant source of microplastics.

These are “tiny plastic fragments produced by the degradation of larger plastics or manufactured for certain products, found in our water, air, food and – increasingly – human blood and tissues", explains Mohamed Abdallah, professor of environmental chemistry at the University of Birmingham.

The team, led by Abdallah, found that hot tea contains 60 microplastic particles per litre (MPs/L), or around 12 to 15 per cup. By comparison, a litre of energy drink averaged 25 microplastics, while the same amount of soft drink averaged 17, suggesting that higher temperatures accelerate the release of microplastics from the tea bag into the beverage.

The same was true of hot tea served in a disposable plastic cup, which contained an average of 22 microplastic particles per cup, compared with 14 in hot tea prepared in a glass mug.

What this means for our health

Scientists don't yet fully understand the implications of microplastics for human health. Photo / 123rf
Scientists don't yet fully understand the implications of microplastics for human health. Photo / 123rf

“As it stands, most studies on microplastics and their health effects have been conducted in animals and gut simulator models, with the latter showing disruptions to the gut microbiome,” says Dr Sammie Gill, a registered dietitian and British Dietetic Association spokesperson.

However, some experts have cast doubt on the reliability of these studies, which may have been affected by contamination and false positives.

This means there are still significant gaps in our knowledge, as scientists do not yet fully understand the implications of microplastics for human health. Nevertheless, as we ingest these tiny fragments of plastic and they gradually accumulate in our organs, blood and tissues, they remain a cause for concern.

How to reduce your microplastic intake

To reduce your microplastic intake, Abdallah advises steering clear of tea served in plastic cups with plastic lids. That includes the takeaway paper cup, which is often lined with plastic. “Opt for your usual glass or ceramic mug,” he advises.

Meanwhile, Gill suggests “switching to loose leaf tea or buying self-fill paper teabags with cotton drawstrings”.

Reduced iron absorption

The characteristically dry, somewhat bitter taste of tea is the result of tannins – compounds found in a range of plant-based foods and beverages. While tannins boast a number of impressive health benefits, including anti-inflammatory and antioxidant properties, “they can bind to iron in certain foods, rendering it unavailable for absorption in the digestive tract”, says Gill. Iron is needed to transport oxygen around the body, as well as for energy production and muscle function.

Black tea tends to contain the highest levels of tannins, while green, white and herbal teas generally contain fewer. This depends on the quality of the tea, the oxidation process and steeping time.

One review published in the Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics found that drinking tea primarily limited the absorption of non-heme (plant-based) iron. However, it concluded that this was most likely to affect those at risk of iron deficiency, such as pregnant women and vegetarians.

How to protect your iron levels

The researchers advised those at risk to drink tea an hour after eating, or to brew it between meals. As tannins primarily affect plant-based iron, those following vegan or vegetarian diets may also benefit from these guidelines.

Limiting tea intake to three or fewer cups, or around 710ml per day, is likely to be a safe range for most people. However, if you are concerned about tannin intake, Gill suggests pairing iron-rich breakfast foods such as nuts or dried fruit with foods or drinks high in vitamin C, such as orange juice. These can help to increase iron absorption, although the effects are reported to be relatively small, she notes.

Caffeine, anxiety and sleep disruption

Black tea, such as English Breakfast or Earl Grey, typically contains around 40 to 70mg of caffeine per cup. The same measure of black coffee contains around 95mg.
Black tea, such as English Breakfast or Earl Grey, typically contains around 40 to 70mg of caffeine per cup. The same measure of black coffee contains around 95mg.

Caffeine is a double-edged sword. “While we know it can be beneficial in the right amounts, over-reliance can cause problems,” Gill says.

Black tea, such as English Breakfast or Earl Grey, typically contains around 40 to 70mg of caffeine per cup, while green tea contains about 35mg, although this varies significantly depending on steeping time, brew strength and tea quality. Most herbal and fruit teas are naturally caffeine-free. By comparison, the same measure of black coffee contains around 95mg.

For most people, consuming up to 400mg of caffeine a day (200mg during pregnancy) is considered safe. This equates to roughly six cups of tea, Gill says.

However, drinking more than this “can trigger anxiety, irritability and restlessness”, she warns. Relying on caffeine to get through the day is also more likely to affect sleep, while consuming caffeine when stressed may amplify the body’s stress response.

How to manage your caffeine intake

Ensure you limit your caffeine intake to 400mg or less each day.

It is also a good idea to cut back on caffeine after lunchtime, Gill says.

“Caffeine has a quarter-life of around 10 to 12 hours, meaning that if you consume it at midday, a quarter is still in your brain close to midnight, which can disrupt sleep.”

She advises opting for herbal teas in the afternoon, as these are naturally caffeine-free.

Digestive side effects

While a warm mug of tea can be soothing, it also has the potential to aggravate stomach problems such as acid reflux and heartburn. This is because caffeine stimulates the stomach to produce more acid, which can irritate the stomach lining.

One 2019 study found that drinking coffee, tea and soda was associated with an increased risk of acid reflux, while drinking water reduced this risk. However, the evidence is conflicting – another 2019 study found that drinking coffee or tea was not associated with reflux symptoms.

“Responses vary from person to person, so not everyone who is prone to upper gut symptoms will need to avoid tea,” Gill says. “However, if your tea does trigger symptoms, go for decaffeinated, fruit teas or herbal teas instead.”

Consuming high levels of tannins may also cause nausea in some people, especially when tea is consumed on an empty stomach, Gill says.

This is more likely to be a problem for people with sensitive digestive systems, as tannins can irritate the stomach lining and increase stomach acidity. Over-brewing tea releases more tannins and can intensify this effect.

Plus, “if you have a sensitive gut – for example, irritable bowel syndrome – caffeine can worsen symptoms such as pain, bloating and diarrhoea because caffeine stimulates gut motility", Gill says. “Reducing caffeine can improve gut symptoms.”

How to make tea gentler on your stomach

To minimise these effects, Gill advises adding milk to tea or drinking it alongside a snack. Ensuring that tea is not brewed for too long is another way to keep tannin and caffeine levels within a tolerable range. Alternatively, opt for teas that are gentler on the stomach, such as decaffeinated, ginger or mint teas.