The best and worst exercises for your gut health

Damon Syson
Lactate, a by-product of the breakdown of glucose during exercise, appears to be a crucial factor in the relationship between gut health and physical exertion. Photo / Getty Images
Lactate, a by-product of the breakdown of glucose during exercise, appears to be a crucial factor in the relationship between gut health and physical exertion. Photo / Getty Images

From HIIT to walking, the right balance of movement can boost your microbiome – but too much may do more harm than good.

When we think of optimising our gut health, we tend to focus on what we eat and drink, but consuming gut-friendly kimchi, kombucha and kefir is just one part of the jigsaw.

Studies have shown that the exercise we do also has a significant impact on our microbiome.

Aimee Newton of Well&Gut, a registered dietitian specialising in IBS and gut health, has more than 16 years’ experience working with athletes preparing for events such as marathons, triathlons and Channel swims.

“Physical activity can improve our gut health in many different ways,” Newton says, “including increasing the diversity of our gut bacteria.”

Why does exercise boost our gut health?

Numerous studies have found that athletes possess more of some of these beneficial bacteria than people with a sedentary lifestyle. However, it is still not clear how exercise changes the community of microorganisms, or what the optimal concentration of different bacteria is.

“What we do know is that exercise essentially helps to make the gut barrier stronger and less permeable,” says Newton. “At the same time, it can reduce inflammation in our gut, which supports a better environment for more bacteria to grow.”

Lactate, a by-product of the breakdown of glucose during exercise, appears to be a crucial factor in the relationship between gut health and physical exertion. Our gut bacteria can use it as fuel and convert it into beneficial short-chain fatty acids such as butyrate, which acts as an important fuel for the cells lining the gut and influences inflammation levels and immune cells.

“Rather than lactate being a waste product resulting from intense exercise,” Newton explains, “it can actually be recycled by the gut microbiome into something helpful. But the system needs to be balanced; if lactate levels increase too much [for example, during high-intensity exercise], this can lower the pH of the gut excessively, which is not a good thing.”

High-intensity exercise over a long duration can cause gut dysbiosis (an imbalance of microorganisms in the gut microbiome) and inflammation.

“Prolonged, high-intensity endurance exercise is particularly problematic, especially long-distance running,” says Newton. “Hot conditions make things worse, as does dehydration and inadequate fuelling.”

But what happens if you are forced to suddenly stop training – due to injury, for example? “The gut microbiome tends to shift back towards its baseline, its pre-training state,” Newton replies.

“Studies suggest that the microbial diversity you have built up will gradually decline. However, when athletes take a break from training, that decline is much slower because they have built up more microbial diversity and greater resilience.”

The best exercises for your gut health, ranked from worst to best

Marathon or triathlon training

Extensive evidence shows that long-distance running and other endurance events can cause gastrointestinal distress. Photo / Paul Taylor
Extensive evidence shows that long-distance running and other endurance events can cause gastrointestinal distress. Photo / Paul Taylor

Irregular or long-lasting training has a negative impact on the microbiome, and there is extensive evidence that long-distance running and other endurance events can cause gastrointestinal distress.

During longer sessions, blood flow is diverted away from the digestive system, as it is needed by the muscles. This reduces oxygen supply to the gut, which can cause intestinal permeability, also known as “leaky gut”. The intestinal lining becomes damaged, allowing undigested food particles, toxins and bacteria to leak into the bloodstream.

“With less blood flow in your gut, you are not going to digest things as well,” says Newton. “Your stomach does not empty as quickly and your gut motility may be impaired. That is why long-distance runners sometimes get diarrhoea or so-called ‘runner’s trots’. The pounding action of running can irritate the intestines, which is why people experience more gastrointestinal symptoms with running than they do with cycling or swimming.

“If you are thinking of running a marathon, it is important to find ways to manage the stress on your gut,” Newton says. “Running long distances, especially in hot conditions, is likely to cause intestinal permeability. But if you stay hydrated and make sure your nutrition is right, those risks will be minimised.”

Eating the correct foods and allowing adequate time for recovery are key. “If you are sleeping well, this will allow your gut to recover. I worked with one client who was getting up ridiculously early to fit in training sessions. They were sacrificing their sleep to do that, which had a knock-on effect on their gut health.”

Yoga

Yoga primarily benefits the gut indirectly, via the gut–brain axis, rather than by actively altering gut bacteria.
Yoga primarily benefits the gut indirectly, via the gut–brain axis, rather than by actively altering gut bacteria.

There is some scientific evidence that yoga supports gut health. However, as Newton explains, this type of gentle exercise benefits our gut indirectly, via the gut–brain axis, rather than by actively altering gut bacteria. “Unlike aerobic exercise”, she says, “there is no evidence that yoga or Pilates is a primary driver of microbial diversity and short-chain fatty acid production.”

Stress is a major trigger for gut symptoms, for example in people with irritable bowel syndrome. When we are stressed, the body goes into “fight-or-flight” mode, which inhibits the parasympathetic nervous system (PSNS). This impairs digestion and increases inflammation.

“Exercise is one of the best ways to reduce stress,” says Newton, “and because it focuses on breath and movement and has a meditative aspect, yoga is particularly effective.”

Regular yoga stimulates the PSNS and activates the vagus nerve, which should improve gut motility (the movement and efficiency of the digestive system) and reduce hypersensitivity within the gut. “Some yoga poses can also help to relieve gas by aiding gut motility,” Newton says. “When food moves more efficiently through your digestive system, it relieves the gas that gets trapped when things are stagnant.”

HIIT (High-intensity interval training)

In terms of gut health, dietitian Aimee Newton describes HIIT as “a bit of a double-edged sword, because it is beneficial, but only in the right dose".
In terms of gut health, dietitian Aimee Newton describes HIIT as “a bit of a double-edged sword, because it is beneficial, but only in the right dose".

Studies have shown that higher cardiorespiratory fitness (the body’s ability to transport oxygen to muscles) increases beneficial bacteria in the gut microbiome, particularly strains that produce butyrate.

Most fitness experts agree that one of the most efficient ways to improve cardiorespiratory fitness is through high-intensity interval training (HIIT), which involves short bursts of maximum-effort activity followed by brief periods of rest.

“My interpretation of this,” says Newton, “is something like 30 seconds of intense activity followed by 30 seconds off – for maybe 10 to 15 minutes. Or you could do the Tabata protocol, consisting of eight rounds of 20 seconds of all-out effort followed by 10 seconds of rest.”

In terms of gut health, Newton describes HIIT as “a bit of a double-edged sword, because it is beneficial, but only in the right dose. It may temporarily increase gut permeability, but if you are only doing it for a short period and allow proper recovery, it is unlikely to cause any long-term problems.

“Again, recovery is very important. It would not be sensible to do HIIT five days in a row. One or two sessions per week is sufficient.”

Strength training

Resistance training (with weights, bands or body weight) is beneficial for gut health, but it works differently from aerobic exercise.
Resistance training (with weights, bands or body weight) is beneficial for gut health, but it works differently from aerobic exercise.

Resistance training (with weights, bands or body weight) is beneficial for gut health, but it works differently from aerobic exercise.

“Strength training does not significantly change the gut microbiome composition,” Newton says. “It does not consistently increase microbial diversity within the gut, but it does seem to improve gut barrier function.

“Some studies have shown lower zonulin levels in people who strength train, a type of protein thought to be beneficial for the gut. It can also increase mucin production, which supports the gut lining and therefore immune function.”

Overall, the suggestion is that this type of exercise may help the gut to become more resilient, with less inflammation – though how it does this is not yet clear.

“Evidence is emerging about the gut–muscle axis”, Newton adds, “where the gut microbiota plays a direct and profound role in regulating muscle health, metabolism and inflammation. But that research is still in its early stages.”

Swimming, cycling or walking

Studies show that moderate-intensity aerobic activity consistently increases microbial diversity, beneficial bacteria and short-chain fatty-acid producers, supporting the gut and lowering inflammation.
Studies show that moderate-intensity aerobic activity consistently increases microbial diversity, beneficial bacteria and short-chain fatty-acid producers, supporting the gut and lowering inflammation.

“Research suggests that moderate-intensity aerobic activity is the best exercise for gut health,” Newton says.

Moderate-intensity exercise includes brisk walking, cycling (not long-distance or sprinting) and swimming. Studies show that it consistently increases microbial diversity, beneficial bacteria and short-chain fatty-acid producers, supporting the gut and lowering inflammation.

The UK’s National Health Service recommends that adults do at least 150 minutes of moderate-intensity aerobic activity per week.

“Quite a lot of research has been done into this,” Newton says, “but the main limitation is that it has looked at different intensities, durations and types of exercise, so it is difficult to draw strong conclusions. Overall, though, the evidence is clear: doing some form of moderate cardiovascular activity on a regular basis will benefit your gut health.”

For optimal results, this should be combined with strength training. “You should also try to incorporate some daily movement – things like walking or yoga – because that will aid gut motility and reduce stress.

“Consistency is also important. If you do six weeks of exercise but then do nothing for the rest of the year, the benefits will soon be lost. Smaller, achievable amounts done regularly, such as twice a week, every week, are more effective for long-term gut health.”