Opinion

Job interview etiquette: Why Gen Z is judged for bringing iced coffee

Opinion by
Imogene Bedford is a live news journalist with the New Zealand Herald.
Is bringing an iced coffee to a job interview really that bad? Photo / Getty Images
Is bringing an iced coffee to a job interview really that bad? Photo / Getty Images

The rattling ice and slurping straw are the sounds of a generation being judged.

Much like avocado toast, the much-maligned meal thwarting millennial home buying, iced coffee has become a vessel for anxieties about the young.

Bringing a drink to a job interview is supposedly the ultimate Gen Z faux pas, according to a recent TikTok video.

Florida recruiter Caitlin Wehniainen, who says she works mainly with Fortune 500 companies, scolded young jobseekers for what she described as a lack of professionalism when they BYO frappuccino to a job interview.

“It looks like you went to Target, then you went to Starbucks. Now you’re stopping by your interview, then you’re on to the next thing. It looks a little too casual for me,” she says in the video.

Hiring managers took to the comments to claim the benign act suggests poor time management. Why waltz in with a half-finished drink, except because you couldn’t finish it before walking in?

Others say it can be a sign your attention is not entirely on the interview, that the coffee is an unnecessary distraction, one that, perhaps worst of all, leaves a final indictment of character in the form of a condensation ring.

As a zillennial, on the cusp of being Gen Z and a millennial, the discourse seems a stretch. I’ve never thought to bring a drink into an interview, though I struggle to see why it should matter if I had.

Does being painfully slow at consuming a $7 beverage mean I am incompetent, distracted or just mindful of a weak bladder?

A quick canvass of our newsroom suggested whether bringing an emotional support drink to an interview is okay depends on what generation you ask.

“They are literally sucking milk while being asked to be treated like adults,” said one Gen X.

A millennial said she wouldn’t bring an iced coffee to an interview. “But I might just be envious of those who have the giant cajones to loudly suck on a straw and rattle ice cubes right after being asked about strengths and weaknesses.”

Another Gen X colleague agreed. “Mostly because I am clumsy and would likely spill it over myself. But also because it’s not a date.”

“Any coffee is bad, but iced coffee just seems so much worse,” said another millennial. “I can’t stop thinking about the wet, condensation-covered handshake. Wait, do Gen Z believe in handshakes?”

“You’re there to talk, not sip. Eat and drink in your own time, not someone else’s,” said a Gen Z.

A millennial and senior editor had the simplest response: “Who cares?”

The disagreement seems representative of a widening gap in what constitutes appropriate work behaviour.

Gen Z have emerged into a challenging workforce post-pandemic, with national youth unemployment rising to 17%, and underutilisation at 36%.

Years of remote work and the advancement of AI have changed the job hunt. For many young people, the experience has become as impersonal as it is demoralising.

Many CVs are never looked at by a human, screened out by software that reduces a career to a series of data points and keywords.

After rounds of psychometric testing and personality tests and take-home assignments, the job interview is the final hurdle before a corporate life structured around coffee runs.

When I asked fellow Gen Z professionals, responses varied by industry.

A friend working in law was adamant it is uncouth to bring any drink to a job interview, while a creative said she had been to interviews held in a cafe. Perhaps unsurprisingly, the more prestigious the industry appears, the more rigid the etiquette.

At risk of sounding sanctimonious, I can’t help but feel there is something adjacent to elitism in the discourse.

It wasn’t long ago that tattoos were considered the height of unprofessionalism, a barrier that kept associations with the working class out of offices.

While iced coffee is hardly adjacent to the sickle and hammer, there might still be something to be said about the symbolic weight attached to frivolity.

Rather than marking you as poor, perhaps the humble latte marks you as entitled.

Much like a first date, an interview is for putting your best foot forward more than being honest.

With only a few minutes to make the right impression, it’s probably better to finish your coffee before you head into a job interview – however right or wrong.

But first dates are also about assessing whether the fit is right in both directions. Some would argue being rejected over something so minute tells you more about the workplace than it says about you.

And by 2030, Gen Z will make up about a third of New Zealand’s workforce. Baby boomers won’t be setting the dress code much longer.