I blamed alcohol for getting breast cancer. Was I wrong?

Dr Liz O’Riordan
"I was a proud member of a society which you could only join if you drank half a pint of everything on tap behind the bar in one go." Photo / File
"I was a proud member of a society which you could only join if you drank half a pint of everything on tap behind the bar in one go." Photo / File

When Dr Liz O’Riordan went back to work as a breast cancer surgeon after her own diagnosis, she had “a kind of PTSD”.

I started drinking in the sixth form, usually Martini Rosso and Malibu and pineapple, because it felt like something exciting to do during my A-levels while trying to get the grades to be a doctor. It was when I got to medical school in Cardiff that it quickly got out of hand.

I went a bit mad. It was the culture in the Nineties. I was a proud member of a society which you could only join if you drank half a pint of everything on tap behind the bar in one go – lager, beers, cider, stout – and if you did it, you got a T-shirt (it was a pint for the boys). The students had their own bar in the grounds of the hospital. It was where you flirted, found your friends and decompressed after dissecting bodies or, later, seeing patients on the ward.

I liked the way alcohol made me feel. When I was drunk, I wasn’t the geeky schoolgirl. It gave me the courage to flirt, to become a different person.

When my drinking took a dangerous turn

After my exams in my second year, I was taken to A&E by my friends with alcohol poisoning. I went missing and they finally found me under a table in the nightclub. I had vomited so badly that they didn’t need to pump my stomach but I was put on a drip. I was almost proud. Alcohol poisoning had given me a new status. I wasn’t a nerd any more.

Another time, I was sick all over a friend’s jacket. I had no memory of getting home that night. It was terrifying. I could have choked in bed on my vomit, somebody could have taken advantage of me. I could have died from the poisoning.

At the time, as a qualified junior doctor, I was working 100 hours a week, seeing traumatic things. The presence of drink was always there. If you weren’t on call, you were drinking with your friends.

A friend had to tell me one day that she thought I was drinking too much. On one social occasion, I had no memory of telling one of the professors that he looked like a paedophile because of his moustache. I was mortified.

When I connected alcohol with the risks – and the guilt began

Slowly, I started to grow up. Drinking became nice wine with a meal. When I bought my own house in my 20s, sometimes I caught myself thinking: “I’m drinking two bottles of wine a week, this isn’t good.” I slowed down again.

I got married in 2011 when I was 37. I was a breast-cancer surgeon by then, having trained at the Royal Marsden, and my husband was and still is a surgeon too. I was really fit, into cycling and triathlons. My husband and I had started drinking much less by then. We were the healthiest we’d ever been.

I have a history of having benign cysts in my breasts, so when I found a lump in my left breast in 2015, aged 40, I assumed it was just another one. But the lump was identified as two different types of cancer, with a high risk of recurrence.

It was in the first couple of weeks after diagnosis, when I was waiting for chemotherapy, that the guilt started to flood in. Why me? I was young and it was rare at the age of 40. I went on to have a mastectomy and my lymph nodes out.

And then I started blaming myself. What if all those years of knocking back wine and spirits had done this to me? Was it really my fault? It is very easy to think cancer happens because of something you have done, even though rationally, the doctor in me knew that no one can tell you why you get breast cancer (unless there is a genetic component).

A woman’s lifetime risk of getting breast cancer is one in seven. But a quarter of all breast cancers are diagnosed in women 75 and over. I see now that it was really unhealthy of me to lay all that blame and worry on myself, but lots of people do it. You want answers.

But even then, during my chemo I’d have a glass of bubbly to celebrate a good day. I’d think to myself: “I’ve got cancer. What’s the point [in not]? I may as well carry on drinking.”

Breaking down the actual risk – what the numbers mean

Alcohol raises a woman’s risk of breast cancer by 13%. So you might think that 13 out of 100 women get breast cancer from drinking. But it’s important to remember – and for a long time I didn’t – that it’s a relative risk. This means that the risk is relative to your own life: how old you are, whether you are overweight, whether you exercise.

So, for example, if you are in your 30s, your risk of breast cancer is about five in 1000 women. So if you drink two units of alcohol a day, every day, your risk increases by 13%, which is 5.65 in 1000 women, an extra “half a woman” in 1000 – quite a small increase in risk.

In your 50s, the overall risk in all women rises to 24 out of 1000 – so then factor in a woman drinking two units a day and that risk becomes 27 women in 1000, so an extra three women in 1000 will get breast cancer when alcohol is factored in.

Surviving cancer as a cancer surgeon – and the guilt returning

When I went back to work as a breast cancer surgeon, I had a kind of PTSD. With my patients, I knew what it felt like to be in their position, but there can only be one patient in the room.

And then the cancer came back. As a result of all the treatment, my left arm didn’t work properly, which meant that I could no longer work as a surgeon. I’d lost my career aged 43, my (financial) independence, I’d been made infertile, had instant menopause with no recourse to hormone replacement therapy. I felt such loss and grief, along with the increased fear of how well I’d recover.

The blame started again. You have these crazy thoughts in your head such as “I drank after chemo – it’s why the treatment hadn’t worked”, and that it was a result of the way I’d behaved in my early years as a student and young doctor.

Now, I’m cancer-free again and I finally understand that nothing about cancer is rational or logical. And that the numbers outlining the risks are often misunderstood.

Did alcohol cause my own cancer?

The honest truth is that I will never know and no one can tell me, because for most women, we still can’t pinpoint a single cause of breast cancer. The biggest risk factors are getting older, having breasts and bad luck. (Genetic inherited mutations only account for 10% of cases.) Alcohol can contribute to that bad luck.

I see now that my drinking might have caused one of the many mutations needed for my healthy breast cells to become cancerous, but it’s rarely the only thing. If alcohol caused breast cancer in a “neat”, predictable way, every female heavy drinker would get breast cancer and they don’t, and plenty of women who are teetotal get breast cancer.

All those years during which I blamed myself, I was being not only cruel, but also inaccurate. Alcohol might have triggered some of the mutations, but there were many more.

I have also slowly learnt to accept that my cancer wasn’t my punishment. How could I have known back then what would happen to me? All I can do is decide what I do with my life going forward. I might have got breast cancer anyway.

I’ve had two hangovers in the past 10 years and I never want to feel like that again. The breast cancer drugs I’ve taken have changed my taste buds and I don’t need alcohol any more. I might have a small sip of champagne in memory of my late parents or an Aperol spritz on holiday because it was their favourite drink and that’s it.

When people ask me now about safe drinking, I tell them that having something nice when you fancy it is fine. But make it an occasion, not the norm. If your brain says “work finished, pour wine”, that is not a treat, that’s a habit. You’re on autopilot. Have a non-alcoholic beer. Take a shower or go for a walk instead. But if you want a glass of something nice, have it and enjoy it.

Now I’m in my 50s, I’ve had some great fun dancing sober at weddings. I needed my experience to finally realise that I can have just as much fun without alcohol in my life.

– As told to Louise Carpenter

How alcohol can raise your risk of cancer

When you drink, your body breaks alcohol down into a toxic chemical, acetaldehyde, which can damage your DNA, causing mutations, which stop your cells repairing damage.

Alcohol increases estrogen levels in your body, which is like kindling to estrogen-sensitive breast cancer cells.

Alcohol makes other carcinogens more harmful, especially tobacco. If you smoke and drink at the same time, you are multiplying your risk of cancers of the mouth and throat.

Drinking heavily can affect your gut biome, making the lining of your gut leaky and allowing toxic chemicals into your bloodstream.

It causes a state of chronic inflammation that can drive cancer cell growth, while suppressing your immune system, which can affect how well your immune cells detect and fight early cancer cells.

  • Dr Liz O’Riordan is a retired breast surgeon, cancer survivor, campaigner and educator. Her YouTube channel is @DrLizORiordan.