Opinion

Hannah McQueen: How to protect your career over 50 – and why hard work isn’t enough

Opinion by
Hannah McQueen
As we get older, many of us actively want to become less of a show pony. There's nothing wrong with that, but there is a risk in becoming invisible. Photo / Getty Images
As we get older, many of us actively want to become less of a show pony. There's nothing wrong with that, but there is a risk in becoming invisible. Photo / Getty Images

On Saturday I caught up with a friend I’ve known for years. She’s in her early 50s, whip-smart, funny and at the absolute top of her game professionally.

But she isn’t happy in her job. She wants to leave and find something else.

The problem is, she’s scared to.

“I don’t think I’d be hireable,” she told me. “I’m almost in my mid-fifties, after all.”

I raised an eyebrow.

Somewhere along the way, she has absorbed the message that the number attached to her age might matter more to a prospective employer than everything she has accumulated.

Perhaps she’s right to worry. The Retirement Commission found almost a quarter of our workforce was already aged 55-plus, yet 80% of employers surveyed had no specific strategy for attracting or retaining older workers.

More recent research found 71% of New Zealand workers over 50 believed ageism was prevalent in our workplaces; 85% thought finding a job became harder with age, and 29% had decided not even to apply for a job because they thought their age would count against them.

Don’t think this is older people interpreting rejection personally. One large US study, first published in 2015 and revised in 2017, sent more than 40,000 fictitious job applications to employers. Applicants were comparable except for their ages. Call-back rates fell as applicants got older, particularly for women.

Same skills. Different age. Different outcome.

So yes, ageism exists.

The ‘relevance quotient’

Employment specialist Lisa Oakley spends an uncomfortable amount of her working life sitting across the table from organisations that want someone gone.

She helped me see another layer to the story.

Her argument isn’t that ageism isn’t real. But she thinks this is more to do with relevance and perception, rather than ageism itself.

That distinction took me back to being a graduate.

My first proper job was at a Big Four consulting firm. I was bright-eyed, ambitious and fairly convinced the world should operate on merit.

One day my manager said to me: “Hannah, getting promoted well is about perception”.

Surely progress should be about the quality of your work and what you achieve? The idea that I should be thinking about how other people perceived me felt less noble. It felt gross.

Most of us were taught not to brag. Put your head down. Do the work. Let the results speak for themselves. The Kiwi way.

Oakley reminds me that the person 20 years younger may be playing by completely different rules. They’re visible. They’re communicating upwards. They’re making sure their boss knows what they’re contributing. I find myself rolling my eyes at this whippersnapper.

“Whether you are meaningfully contributing is not the point, it’s whether you are perceived to be contributing,” she says.

Oakley calls it RQ or relevance quotient: how marketable and useful we remain as the environment around us changes. But relevance isn’t enough. People need to see it. And as we get older, we have less luxury to ignore that second part.

Show pony or workhorse?

Oakley gives me the example of a senior operations executive she had been asked to help exit. He was good. Dependable. A workhorse.

On leaving the organisation, he reflected that his mistake was believing doing good work was enough. Meanwhile, the people around him were constantly communicating: I’ve got that in hand. Here’s where I’m up to. It’s finished.

He regarded that as “show ponying”. His employer saw it as responsiveness, communication and engagement. Perception matters.

By the time he understood the difference, the decision about him had largely been made.

“He didn’t realise that he needed to be a show pony,” Oakley says. He had spent his career assuming that if he did the job well, people would notice. Most don’t.

I like the workhorses. And as we get older, many of us actively want to become less of a show pony.

We’ve done the climbing. We’ve proved ourselves. We don’t necessarily want the spotlight anymore. We’d quite like to do good work, go home and perhaps play a little smaller.

Nothing wrong with that. But there is a risk in becoming invisible.

Oakley suggests making it easy for your boss to know what you’re doing and what you’ve achieved. Make it obvious that you have things in hand.

Because the uncomfortable truth is that if we fail to adapt to the modern workplace, we run the risk of being discriminated against.

Momentum is what people notice

There’s another assumption we don’t talk about enough: that if we want to keep working, we’ll be allowed to.

In my previous life as a financial adviser, I’d ask people when they planned to retire. Occasionally someone would confidently say 70 or 75.

Fine.

But that retirement plan just made two enormous assumptions: that you’ll still be physically capable of doing your job at 75, and that somebody will still want to employ you.

That’s an increasingly dangerous assumption in a business environment too precarious to offer certainty to anyone. So start role-playing the scenarios early.

If you were made redundant tomorrow, how easy would it be to secure another job? The risk isn’t that you’ll never work again. It’s how long it takes, and how far your salary might fall.

That’s why you need a buffer. The size of your buffer dictates how long you can last between roles and how fussy you can afford to be.

Then go wider. What else could you do? Who else knows what you’re capable of? Does all your security rest on one employer continuing to want you? Could you consult? Contract? Start a small business? Rent out a room? Build a side hustle?

Stay agile. Flirt with possibility. Understand your options. If you don’t like them, do something about it. Don’t drift. Make your contribution visible. Because the younger ones are.

They may not bring the same experience, but eagerness can easily be mistaken for momentum, and momentum is what people notice.

Which brings me back to my friend. I don’t think she’s scared of getting older. She’s scared that getting older has quietly reduced her choices, that despite everything she knows and everything she’s achieved, the market may no longer see her the same way.

Her experience gives her a head start, but no immunity.

And perhaps that’s what my bright-eyed 22-year-old self didn’t understand when my manager told me progress was about perception. I thought good work should speak for itself. It does, but it’s competing with louder voices.

It might feel like a silly game. Play it anyway.

Lisa Oakley’s tip for staying relevant at work:

  • Keep learning. Not necessarily another degree. Learn something that makes you curious and slightly uncomfortable. Learn enough about coding and AI tools to understand what might change in your work.
  • Keep your contribution visible.  If this doesn’t come naturally to you, get a coach.
  • Keep building relationships.  Your network is a form of resilience, so keep connections current and strong.  Get outside the same handful of people you’ve known for 25 years.

Employers have a role to play too

Ageism isn’t only a fairness issue; it’s a business risk. Navigating an ageing workforce is tricky, and getting it wrong can mean losing capable people, experience, judgment, relationships and institutional knowledge.

The best workforce decisions aren’t based on age or perception. But how do you see past inherent biases to recognise real value? That’s the employer’s challenge – and what I’ll explore next week.

Hannah McQueen is the founder and director of Age Brightly. She is also the host of The Next Bit podcast on iHeart Radio.