Goldfish dust. Filthy clothes. Rocks. Is every parent driving a trashmobile?

Annie Atherton
You can have a clean car, or you can have kids. Photo / 123rf
You can have a clean car, or you can have kids. Photo / 123rf

If someone broke into my car today, they might be just grossed out enough to regret their decision. Under the piles of stinky shoes and soiled sweatshirts, they would find anywhere between one and three empty juice boxes, a mouldy Tupperware, and enough dead leaves and debris for a family of rodents to build a nest. (Collected “for the fairies,” so I haven’t the heart to throw it all out … yet.) It’s a harrowing scene, but according to other parents, it’s also par for the course.

“I’m pretty sure my family could last in the Alaskan wilderness for at least 30 days, based on the amount of clothing and food scraps that are in my car,” said Emmalee Bierly, a licensed marriage and family therapist and mother of two in West Chester, Pennsylvania.

In addition to running a business and hosting the podcast ShrinkChicks, Bierly frequently plays Uber driver to a toddler, a 7-year-old and their friends, one of whom recently commented on the sordid state of her vehicle. “They’re brutally honest,” she said.

Her situation is hardly unique. Parents frequently take to social media to post joking images of their trashmobiles. As simple as the problem may be, it is oddly difficult to solve. As soon as the chaos is cleared, it seems to refill nearly instantly. Car trash cans fill up within hours. Kids haul home new art every day. This presents something of a catch-22: ignore it, and the mess will multiply; try to tackle this Sisyphean endeavour, and you run the risk of driving yourself insane. As with many domestic dilemmas, it may be that the only solution is self-knowledge: to know how much chaos one can handle, and to strive for that sweet spot between acceptance and motivation. You may never quite find the answer, but you may at least see the humour in it all.

Alex Anguish, a real estate agent and mother of three in Reno, Nevada, recalls a time when her kids were younger that she posted a photo of her car that was “so repulsive” that a friend reached out to say it made him second-guess having a child.

While social media can provide comedic catharsis, it also can perpetuate unrealistic standards. That’s one reason Cassie Charvat, a content creator and mother of two in Garner, North Carolina, decided to post a video of herself cleaning out her car. Leaning over a massive pile, she excavates art projects, toys, muffins, mail and even bills. “As mums who scroll social media, there’s such a perspective that things have to be perfect,” she said. “I see all these people with clean, beautiful cars, and I wanted to show other people, especially mums, that it’s okay for our cars to look like this.”

Then there are times when we have no choice but to showcase our car’s interiors. A broker recently asked Anguish for a ride to a showing, and, she said, “my heart dropped, thinking, ‘Oh my gosh, is my car clean?’” I can say, as someone who accepts rides from friends and colleagues often, I am both amused and empathetic when I see someone scramble to hide their clutter.

Bierly says she used to get more upset about the mess, but it only created tension between her and her family. She’s since made a conscious decision to loosen up about it.

“My mental health is better when I let things go,” she said. “I would much rather be inside, sitting down with my daughter as she does her homework, giving her a snack, than being outside in the car, annoyed at everyone.”

Charvat, meanwhile, says that when she has attempted to declutter, it’s only made her realise why she had so many things stockpiled in the first place: she’s the mum who always has something if you need it, be that a spare diaper, a wipe or a naked Barbie. “Even though it’s messy, I have a rhyme and reason for everything.”

Acceptance doesn’t have to mean giving up entirely. Charvat keeps baskets in the back seat for toys and other items. Some people hang a trash bag on the back of the seat. Anguish has made a rule for herself that any time she fills the gas tank, she uses the time to crawl around the car and throw out garbage. Bierly has made a monthly ritual of tackling the mess with her family – even the 16-month-old carries some things into the house. That way, it’s not a punishment but a fun shared activity as they reflect on why various items are there. Deciding to have firmer boundaries around other areas in one’s home can be a source of solace, as well, Bierly says. Of course, everyone has different tolerance levels for disorder, and some people may find that letting filth fester is worse for their mental health than taking the time to tackle it daily.

Still, even if you’ve mostly accepted the chaos, there can be that moment when you climb into the driver’s seat and feel utterly overwhelmed. That’s when the negative self-talk can start, Bierly says.

“I’ll get in my car and think to myself: ‘Oh my God, I’m such a mess. Other people don’t do this,’” she said. “The reality is, the way that your car looks does not say s*** about you, but it feels like it.”

She encourages people who are struggling to reflect on questions such as: What do I think this mess says about me? Where did I learn that? And what could I be saying to myself instead to undo that learning? After all, the car is where we spend much of our time, and driving with kids can produce unexpected moments of joy and connection. It’s often when kids and teenagers feel more comfortable opening up to their parents, Bierly says. “If I am focusing on the state of my car and not what is really happening, I’m going to miss out on things,” she said.

As for the rocks, leaves and other debris young kids seem so fond of bringing inside? She embraces that, too – to a point. “I’m not going to kill her whimsy, man,” she said. Perhaps we shouldn’t kill our own, either.