At 57, I discovered I’d been switched at birth

Teresa Carter sent her DNA to a genealogy site on a whim. The results turned her world upside down.
At first, Teresa Carter was sure it was a scam. Why else would a perfect stranger keep sending her cryptic messages week after week?
“They went from saying: ‘I have something I have to tell you,’ and ‘There’s something I know that might change your life,’ to ‘Don’t worry, your parents did nothing wrong.’”
For five weeks in the spring of 2020, as the pandemic raged, the then 57-year-old mother-of-two from Huntingdon, Tennessee in the United States did her best to ignore the regular arrivals in her inbox from a woman called Linda*.
“Then came a message claiming that she’d looked at my Facebook page and seen my pictures,” remembers Teresa, who works as a house manager at a performing arts centre. “That’s when I finally snapped. It was time for this to stop.”
In fact, an extraordinary new chapter in her life was just about to begin. She was about to find out she had been switched at birth.
Born in September 1962, Teresa grew up in a small town with Patricia Ann, a stay-at-home mother, and Tommy, whoworked at a metal manufacturer. The eldest of five children, with a younger brother and three sisters, Teresa remembers a busy, happy childhood.
“We didn’t have much money, but we never felt poor. My parents were openly loving towards each other and us and we were always together.”
On family outings, people would often comment on how much her sisters resembled Teresa’s mother, and how much her brother resembled her father. “Whenever someone would ask, ‘And who does Teresa look like?’ Dad would always smile and reply, ‘I guess the milkman!’ It was one of his favourite jokes.
“Everyone would laugh and it never bothered me; I knew that with my blonde hair I stood out in my dark-haired family.”
As she got older, Teresa noticed other differences in terms of temperament and personality. “My siblings talked back, while I was a people-pleaser who hated disappointing anyone, and I was much more academic than they were. None of this seemed strange at the time, nothing more than the differences that exist in every family.”
In the years that followed, there were happy times, like the birth of Teresa’s daughter in 1985 and son in 1990, and difficult ones, like her estrangement from her brother, the loss of Patricia Ann, Teresa’s mother, in 2007, and the end of Teresa’s first marriage the following year.
By March 2019, happily remarried for six years to Lee, a doctor, Teresa’s life had settled into a steady routine. They had no biological children together and when Lee suggested taking an at-home DNA test to discover more about his family tree, she remembers smiling at his excitement.
“My own family tree was written in my grandfather’s Bible, so I knew there would be no surprises for me. But with a two-for-one offer with Ancestry.com, I agreed to join him and send off a sample.”
In this decision, she was far from alone. According to a 2025 YouGov survey, one in five Americans has taken an at-home DNA test. Separate research suggests around 5 million people have done the same thing in the UK.

Teresa describes the results as a “non-occurrence”. After glancing at the page that broke down the percentage of her DNA from different regions of the world, Teresa closed the website and thought no more about it. Then, a year later, the messages from Linda began.
“With the pandemic it was such a dreadful time. I was so worried about Lee, and my best friend’s daughter was very ill. I was driving to her house, unable to shake off Linda’s latest message, when I thought, ‘I’ve no idea why this person is trying to contact me, but I’ve got to end this.’”
‘I didn’t know what to do or how to feel’
Linda continued to stress that there was something Teresa needed to know and that she had photos “that proved something important”.
“At that point I just replied, ‘Send me the photos.’ And almost instantly my phone lit up. I saw a man in his 40s and it was like staring at my own son. There was an older woman [in the picture] and I felt like I was looking in a mirror.”
In tears and with a horrible knot in her stomach, Teresa called Lee, who told her to come home. It was there that she finally spoke to Linda and heard how the people in the photographs held the key to a decades-old secret.
“Linda explained that she’d been adopted, the result of an affair. She had found her biological father and half-siblings, including a brother [David*] who was the man in the picture, a few years earlier.”
It was online DNA tests that Linda (now 59) and then David (now 51) took that brought Teresa into their lives. And, at first, those results were baffling. Linda’s listed Teresa as a half-sibling while David’s results had her as a full-sibling. The pair turned detective, and when they found Teresa’s Facebook page, saw her photos and date of birth, they realised they’d stumbled on something explosive.
“You look just like David’s family,” Linda told Teresa over the phone. “And you grew up 30 minutes away from one another. You were born just one day before David’s oldest sister, Mary*. We think that there’s only one possible explanation: you two were switched at birth.”
“My immediate reaction was, ‘That’s impossible.’” Teresa says. “My brain just couldn’t take in what I was hearing.”
But, as well as shock, there was anger. “I cried, ‘Why did you think that I needed to know this? I didn’t need to know!’ It seemed such an incredible, unbelievable idea.”
The ramifications felt endless and terrifying. The parents who’d raised her, whom she loved, were not her biological family. Yes, this explained the differences she’d noticed during her childhood, but that was no comfort. How could she tell her children, siblings or father?
“Knowing that we didn’t share the same blood, despite being so close, was like a grief. Waking up each day and realising that this wasn’t a nightmare, but my real life, was awful. I didn’t know what to do or how to feel,” Teresa recalls.
Such distress is not unusual. As the popularity of at-home DNA tests has soared, psychologists have begun studying the impact of these revelations. One piece of research in 2023 found that discovering “misattributed paternity” could lead to anxiety, depression and even suicidal thoughts.
In her daily phone calls with Linda, Teresa learned more about her biological family; that, as well as David and Mary, there was another sister, Susan*, and that while her biological mother Alice* was still alive, her biological father had died in 2017. It was yet another blow that Teresa didn’t have the emotional bandwidth to process.
“I couldn’t even think about what my life would have been like if I’d been raised with them. I was just living in survival mode,” she says. Then, after opening up to her children a week later, who were amazed by the news but supportive, Teresa felt compelled to contact Mary, the woman with whom she was now convinced she’d been swapped.
That conversation was surprisingly straightforward, says Teresa. Then she rushed to tell her father, terrified that somehow the news would reach him before she had a chance to tell him herself. When she arrived, with her children by her side, he instantly knew something was wrong. “Somehow, I found the words and his face just froze. He kept saying, ‘No, no, no’. He couldn’t see any resemblance in the photos of David, Mary and Alice that I showed him. He was clearly devastated.”
Finally, Teresa contacted her biological mother. As she tentatively texted Alice, now 83, retired and living just 64 kilometres away, Teresa admits to feeling uncomfortable. “I didn’t really want my dad to know, didn’t want him ever to think that he and Mom were not the best parents. I didn’t want him to think I needed my birth mother for reasons of them not being good enough.”
However, Teresa found a warm, kind and practical woman who was on an emotional rollercoaster of her own since learning that, somehow, she’d taken home the wrong child from the hospital decades before.
Alice’s story
“I was numb, totally frozen. Then came denial, disbelief and finally guilt. How could I not have known my own baby?” says Alice. She was 20 when she gave birth in 1962.
“Back then, they knocked you out with ether during labour, and men weren’t allowed in the delivery room. I was so drugged-up that, although I gave birth at 5.30pm on Thursday, I didn’t really wake up until midnight.”
Alice explains that newborns were not allowed to stay with their mothers but whisked away to the hospital nursery.
“I was still groggy when they brought her in to be fed Thursday evening and then she was gone again. Despite asking for her constantly, it was Friday afternoon before they brought her back.
“When she was in my arms, this beautiful girl with dark hair, my mother-in-law began making a fuss about something. That wasn’t unusual, so I didn’t pay her any attention. Now, I can’t help but think she knew something was wrong.”

Alice was home three days later and thrown into first-time motherhood. The birth faded into the background. It was another eight and a half years before Alice had more children: a blond-haired son and then a daughter. “They were both skinny and fair while Mary was dark. And the build of her body was different. But my husband and I didn’t give that a thought.”
Alice says her relationship with Mary was strained through the teenage years and deteriorated further in adulthood. “It was always complicated,” she says. “After my husband had a stroke in 2016, she was very good at helping me. But after he died in 2017, she distanced herself.”
By 2020, Alice had already faced the shock of discovering her husband’s affair a few years earlier and bonded with Linda (the daughter of that infidelity), who became part of the family.
Then, in April, Linda called her with a question. “She said, ‘I know that you value the truth, and I have something that’s the truth. Would you be interested in me showing it to you?”
Intrigued, Alice and her daughter Susan went to Linda’s house and found themselves looking at pictures of strangers, who at the same time seemed oddly familiar. “One of the women looked like Mary’s twin, and the other looked like me. I listened, stunned, as Linda explained about DNA test results and how she’d found these pictures on the Facebook page of a woman called Teresa.”
Seeing how sure Linda was that the babies had been switched, and despite her shock and guilt, Alice says that it felt like a puzzle piece finally falling into place. “It was so fantastical, like a movie plot. But, at the same time, it answered a lot of questions about Mary, and why she’d always seemed different in some way.”
Waiting for Teresa to respond to Linda’s messages, knowing that she might never do so, was hard. “I wanted to talk to her, to meet my biological child. But I had to respect her feelings. It was her choice what happened next.”
Even when Linda did hear from Teresa five weeks later, there was another hurdle. To know for sure that there had been a switch, Alice and Teresa took another DNA test from Ancestry. The results were definitive.
‘I felt this connection’
In July 2020, Teresa and Alice arranged to meet in a park, halfway between their homes.
“I’d been too terrified to drive, so Lee took me,” recalls Teresa. “Then, suddenly, there she was and it was like looking in a mirror 20 years into the future. She reached out to touch my hand, and I felt this warm feeling, this connection. It was amazing.”
Despite the wave of guilt that followed (“I felt like I was cheating on my parents”), that connection only grew. “We had the same hand movements when we talked, both loved wildflowers and even drove the same car. I felt my jaw drop. All the time I kept thinking, ‘She gave birth to me.’”
“I was pretty quiet and just let her talk,” remembers Alice, “but my mind was racing at 90 miles an hour. I thought, ‘I gave birth to this woman!’ With her energy she reminded me so much of my husband, her biological father.”
The pair shared photos and it brought Alice peace to know that Teresa had grown up with so much love. “If she’d been mistreated in any way that would have been awful. I was so happy that she had a lovely family.”
It’s been six years since Linda first approached Teresa, changing two families forever. But while the DNA is definitive, the question of how two babies went home with the wrong mothers remains frustratingly elusive. Teresa tried to find out what she could, but many of the hospital staff are no longer alive. Despite hearing stories of other switched babies at the same hospital, she’s never come any closer to the truth.
“In my heart I’m sure this didn’t happen by accident. But I’ve had to make peace with the fact that I may never know what really happened that day.”
As for Mary, despite meeting her and even attending counselling sessions with her, Teresa describes their relationship as “difficult”. Mary did contact Tommy, her biological father, once on Facebook, but they never met in person and Tommy has now died. Mary is, however, in touch with her biological siblings, albeit infrequently.
Teresa, though, tries to focus on the positives of this revelation. “I grew up in a wonderful family with amazing parents,” she says firmly. “And now I’ve gained a brother, two sisters and a mother. I’ve learned that I’m strong enough to take the hurdles life throws at me.
“I still catch myself sometimes and can’t believe this has happened to me. But it did, I am still here and I’m proud of that.”
*Names have been changed