Govt puts Hawke’s Bay amalgamation proposal on hold

Central Hawke’s Bay Mayor Will Foley (left), Napier Mayor Richard McGrath and Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum say that while they are disappointed in the delay, they would use the time to strengthen their modelling.
Central Hawke’s Bay Mayor Will Foley (left), Napier Mayor Richard McGrath and Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum say that while they are disappointed in the delay, they would use the time to strengthen their modelling.

Hawke’s Bay’s push for a unitary council has been put on hold after the Government deferred decisions on Head Start proposals until early 2027.

Hastings District, Napier City and Central Hawke’s Bay councils submitted their joint proposal by the August 9 deadline, after the Government launched its Head Start pathway on May 5.

The pathway gave councils three months to develop proposals for reorganising local government, supporting locally led proposals for larger, more efficient unitary authorities.

Wairoa District Council decided to become a unitary council of its own, combining district council and regional council functions for the area.

On Thursday, mayors were sent an email from the Minister for RMA Reform, Chris Bishop, and the Minister of Local Government, Simon Watts, telling them the Cabinet had decided “it would not be making decisions on individual Head Start proposals at this time”.

The letter said while the overall quality of proposals was high, the assessment process identified several common issues that required further consideration.

“None came with the unanimous view of the region, and some needed further analysis before they can progress,” the letter said.

Hastings Mayor Wendy Schollum said today’s announcement was “disappointing” given the community support and alignment achieved between the councils.

“We entered the Head Start process because we believe Hawke’s Bay should have a strong hand in shaping its own future. It was about taking the initiative and developing a locally led solution with our communities, rather than having reform imposed on us through the backstop process,” Schollum said.

Napier Mayor Richard McGrath said that while the announcement was disappointing, the additional time could be used to strengthen the work already undertaken.

“The initial proposal was never intended to be the final blueprint. There is more detailed modelling to do around how a future council could operate, including governance and representation, services and finances,” he said.

Central Hawke’s Bay Mayor Will Foley said ensuring local government services remained affordable and sustainable for communities had been an important consideration in developing the proposal.

“Affordability matters enormously to our communities, and it has been an important part of the work we’ve done to consider the different options for Hawke’s Bay. We can’t expect better outcomes for ratepayers if we simply keep doing things the way we always have,” Foley said.

A spokesperson for the Wairoa District Council said they were pleased the Government was taking more time before deciding which Head Start local government reform proposals should progress to detailed design, as there was still a lot of work to do.

Local Government New Zealand (LGNZ) president Rehette Stoltz said the Government’s inability to decide which proposals would progress had left councils feeling frustrated.

“Councils were put through a rushed process, only for the Government to now acknowledge that the work could not be completed properly in the time available,” Stoltz said.

“Communities will not tolerate ratepayer money being spent on unclear processes that are repeatedly reshaped after the work has been done. Before councils do more work, they need certainty the goalposts won’t be moved again.

“We’ve always said reform must be locally led, not driven from the Beehive.”

Hawke’s Bay councils will continue supporting their Head Start proposal under the revised timeframe, including further modelling and community engagement.

With significant work still required ahead of the 2028 local elections, the councils are seeking clear direction from political parties ahead of the general election on their intentions for local government reform.

LDR is local body journalism co-funded by RNZ and NZ On Air.