‘Exploratory’ discussion on the table for council merger with Gisborne’s neighbours

The Gisborne District Council could open the door to “exploratory” discussions around the Head Start process with neighbouring councils in Ōpōtiki and Wairoa. Pictured clockwise from top left are Waiora Mayor Craig Little, Gisborne Mayor Rehette Stoltz and Ōpōtiki Mayor David Moore.
The Gisborne District Council could open the door to “exploratory” discussions around the Head Start process with neighbouring councils in Ōpōtiki and Wairoa. Pictured clockwise from top left are Waiora Mayor Craig Little, Gisborne Mayor Rehette Stoltz and Ōpōtiki Mayor David Moore.

As smaller councils consider mergers ahead of wider local government reforms, the Gisborne District Council could open the door to “exploratory” discussions with its neighbours.

Gisborne Mayor Rehette Stoltz emphasised that any discussions would remain “non-committal”.

RMA Reform Minister Chris Bishop announced the Head Start pathway last month for councils to fast-track reforms intended to simplify local government.

He said councils that did not create their own proposals would be forced into change after the 2028 local elections and would have plans created on their behalf by central government.

Two or more territorial authorities or unitary authorities could submit a proposal to merge into a new body covering part or all of the region. The deadline for proposals is August 9.

As the Gisborne District Council is already a unitary authority covering the entire region, it is not required to participate in the process.

Stoltz wrote a report for a full council meeting tomorrow () noting this and recommending the council approve undertaking “exploratory discussions with neighbouring councils regarding potential future governance arrangements and regional collaboration opportunities”.

Speaking with the Gisborne Herald, Stoltz emphasised that any discussions, if the council approved her report, would be non-committal and it would be up to the community to decide what happened.

“Even though there is no requirement for us to be a part of the Head Start process, nothing stops us from talking to either Ōpōtiki or Wairoa more formally.

“It will be a very light touch because we are not obliged to do this, but we do want to show that we are aware that there is national reorganisation being talked about.

“Even though we are already a unitary [authority], it is good to temperature check with our community as well as our neighbours.”

Stoltz, also the Local Government NZ (LGNZ) president, said LGNZ had found about 70% of metro mayors, in places like Auckland, Christchurch and Tauranga, were interested in being involved in the head start process.

When it asked the same of rural and provincial councils, about 50% said they would consider the Head Start process.

“Themes that have emerged are that smaller councils are concerned they might lose their local voice and they will be folded into a bigger metro or a bigger area.

“Some mayors also raised a real concern with the shorter timeframe; the Government only gave councils three months.”

Stoltz said questions around what councils might try to achieve through changes or mergers still needed to be asked before any proposals were put in place.

“What we would want to achieve with a bigger scale is better affordability, better services, shared services.

“That is what we would have to do once we take a look at every council’s balance sheets, their debt loads, what services they currently have or offer, and only then can we make the decision to see if that would be beneficial for the ratepayers.”

Wairoa Mayor Craig Little and Ōpōtiki Mayor David Moore have indicated they do not favour a merger with their larger regional neighbours of Hawke’s Bay and Bay of Plenty, respectively.

It is not clear yet if Gisborne will present a more attractive proposition.

Little, a vocal critic of the Government’s short timeframe for the head start process, told the Gisborne Herald Wairoa had held its first community hui about Head Start and mergers on Monday evening.

“We’re hearing loud and clear that they don’t want us to go. They want us to fight it,” Little said. “We’ve got nine more meetings to go right through the community.”

Little said he had a good relationship with Stoltz, and there were similarities between Wairoa and Gisborne when it came to population and geographic make-up, but he was sceptical about any potential merger.

“We will be talking to Gisborne, but I think Gisborne is too big an area for us.

“Dare I say being a part of Gisborne or Hawke’s Bay would take us further away from those communities affected by those decisions.”

Moore recognised the common interests between the Ōpōtiki community and Tairāwhiti, but questioned whether a merger would be in his community’s best interest.

“Tairāwhiti is still recovering from, I believe, ... 16 weather events in the last five years.

“You just have to look at your council’s debt headroom, what still needs fixing, how many bridges still need to be repaired. A small community like ours, how would it be possible to be fairly run from over the hill? It is only a 45-minute drive through the [Waioweka] Gorge, but we might as well be in a different part of the North Island.

“Our community is pretty strongly in favour of not going Tairāwhiti way, but moreso not going towards Tauranga.”

He also shared Little’s concerns about the short timeframe for councils to deliver Head Start proposals.

“It is just not possible to have community consultation in the timeframe that they gave.”