
With Robert Pattinson landing the lead role for the new, Denis Villeneuve-directed James Bond film, the endless speculation about who would become the next 007 is over. It means hotly tipped actors such as James Norton, 40, Jack Lowden, 35, and Aaron Taylor-Johnson, also 35, will have to hang up their tuxedos and get on with their otherwise successful careers.
Pattinson becomes the seventh Bond and will be following in some considerable footsteps: not only the six actors who have played the canonical role, but also many more who were offered the part and turned it down. Here are some of the most interesting – and, in a couple of cases, downright surprising – Bonds that never were.
Dick Van Dyke
This one, admittedly, seems a bit of a stretch, given that the much-loved Dick Van Dyke is usually associated with light comic roles rather than gritty super-assassins – but then, so was Roger Moore, and it never hurt him. Van Dyke recently revealed in an interview with the US chat show Today that Bond producer Albert “Cubby” Broccoli asked him to audition for the part, apparently not bothered by his extraordinary performance in Mary Poppins. But the actor, approached shortly after Sean Connery’s departure from the role following 1967’s You Only Live Twice, turned it down for understandable reasons.
As he recalled: “They said, ‘Would you like to be Bond?’ And I said, ‘Have you heard my British accent?’” Few who saw his cheeky-Cockney-chappie chimney sweep have forgotten the experience. Nonetheless, although he was right to suggest the audience may have had trouble accepting him in the role, he also mused it would have been “a great experience”. That is one way of putting it, certainly.
Richard Burton
In 1959, Richard Burton – long before he was defined by his relationship with Elizabeth Taylor – was one of the hottest stars in Hollywood. He had made his name on the British stage and then established himself as a box office draw with the epic swords-and-sandal drama The Robe. He was approached by Bond author Ian Fleming himself, who was attempting to see if his first James Bond novel, Casino Royale, could be filmed, and considered Burton as having the necessary rugged virility.
The Welsh actor turned down the role on the grounds he was playing King Arthur on Broadway, and, as his great-nephew Guy Masterson later said, “[Burton] told me that he thought it was going to be just another movie”. He was again approached for the part a decade later, after Connery’s exit, but this time he ruled himself out of contention by the time-honoured desire to be paid more money than the producers would offer. Arguably the greatest actor never to have played 007, Burton would have been an incendiary, captivating presence – although, perhaps, we would never have heard of Connery into the bargain.
Cary Grant
Anyone who saw Cary Grant in Hitchcock’s North by Northwest in 1959 would have seen a suave, well-dressed man battling international villains and romancing beautiful women, as well as tossing off well-honed quips. If the role had been an audition piece for Bond, it could not have been a more finely constructed one. Therefore, it was inevitable that Grant would be approached for the role by Bond producers Broccoli and Harry Saltzman when they were preparing to film Dr No. The latter was confident that Grant would take it, not least because the two were personal friends.
However, the actor was in his mid-50s when Broccoli and Saltzman were preparing to make the first Bond film, and so he suggested he was too old to take on the ongoing commitment they wished for; he would play the part once, he offered, and then they could move on with another actor if they so desired. Grant was almost certainly right to be cautious. A greying, ageing Bond was not how Fleming had envisaged the character, and although Grant would undoubtedly have been suave and charismatic, he was more of an interesting “what might have been” than a genuine loss to the role.
James Mason
Ironically, after Grant turned down the part, the next choice for Bond was his North by Northwest co-star and antagonist James Mason. The Yorkshire-born actor was well known for playing a mixture of romantic leads and charismatic villains, and was widely thought to be possessed of one of the two most seductive voices in cinema (the other, naturally, being the aforementioned Burton). He turned down the role for similar reasons to Grant, being in his early 50s at the time of being approached and not wishing to be held in a long-term commitment. He was offered to play Bond twice, rather than once, but it was still not enough.
Less of an obviously heroic choice than many of the actors on this list, Mason was subsequently offered – and accepted – the villainous role of Hugo Drax in 1979’s Moonraker, but was eventually replaced by the French actor Michel Lonsdale in order to satisfy the demands of an Anglo-French co-production.
Lord Lucan
Today, what happened to Richard Bingham, Seventh Earl of Lucan, is one of the great unsolved mysteries of the age: believed to have murdered his children’s nanny in 1974, he vanished shortly afterwards and was declared dead in 1999, despite occasional reported sightings of him since.
Before he purportedly went in for real-life bloodshed, he was suggested for the role of James Bond by his friend Fleming – the two men often gambled together at London’s Clermont Club, and Lucan even drove an Aston Martin to propagate the suave man-about-town image that he desired.
Broccoli was keen on the idea of a real-life aristocrat taking on the role of 007 – ever with a savvy eye for publicity – and offered him a screen test. “He had it all – the looks, the breeding, the pride,” he said. “I seriously wanted to test him for Bond but all he’d say to that was ‘Good heavens!’” Lucan decided his future did not lie in acting and so turned down the potential opportunity. Given we have no record of Lucan appearing in anything else, it’s impossible to say whether he would have been any good, but it nevertheless remains one of the most intriguing “what-ifs” in the history of Bond.
Clint Eastwood
The Broccolis have always shied away from casting a non-British actor as Bond, although many have come close over the years: New Zealander Sam Neill (albeit a man born in Northern Ireland to an English mother), Croatian Goran Višnjić and Frenchman Lambert Wilson were all in the mix at one point. Yet in the late 1960s, when the Bond producers were looking for a new 007 to replace Connery, they considered casting the American star Clint Eastwood, then best known for his appearances in Sergio Leone’s Dollars trilogy.
Unsurprisingly, Eastwood turned down the role, on the grounds he would have felt uncomfortable following on from Connery’s iconic portrayal and that he believed the part should be played by someone British. There is no doubt he would have coped with the physicality and suavity required of the role, but the idea of Clint – the Man with No Name himself – doing an upper-crust English accent is a difficult one to imagine.
Michael Gambon
The late Michael Gambon is now regarded as one of the country’s greatest actors, with an enviable CV behind him that includes everything from Dumbledore to award-winning stage work. Yet he might also have been Connery’s replacement as Bond – as an emerging figure in Laurence Olivier’s National Theatre in the late 1960s, he was one of the country’s most exciting young actors.
However, Gambon also had a reputation for telling outrageous lies to interviewers in order to amuse himself, and so his reasons for turning down the 007 role might have to be taken with a pinch of salt. “I said [to Broccoli] I didn’t want the part because I’m not like him [Bond]. I haven’t got nice hair and I’m a bit fat and he said, ‘Well, the present James Bond [Connery] doesn’t have any hair… it’s a wig’.” Never as classically good-looking as his peers, Gambon would nevertheless have been an intriguing, offbeat choice for the role – an actor, rather than a star.
Timothy Dalton
Aficionados of the Bond series often single out Timothy Dalton’s Bond as the closest to the character that Fleming created: jaded, world-weary and hard, but with a core of bruised romanticism underneath the scarring. It’s a shame he wasn’t given a chance to play the character more than twice, but if matters had been different, he might have had the opportunity.
He was initially offered the role in 1969, but ruled himself out of contention because he considered himself too young, at a mere 23, to give the part the gravitas it needed. He was again considered to replace Roger Moore, who was showing signs of disaffection with the part, a decade later, but once again turned it down; it would not be until he accepted the role for 1987’s The Living Daylights that the world finally got a chance to see what this fine actor would do with the character.
Liam Neeson
Before Taken, Non-Stop and any of the other apparently innumerable action films that Liam Neeson has appeared in over the past 15 years – as well as the delicious spoof The Naked Gun – he could have traded “a particular set of skills” for a licence to kill. In an interview with Rolling Stone, he suggested he and “a bunch of actors” were approached by James Bond producer Barbara Broccoli after the release of Schindler’s List made him an A-list star, and, in Neeson’s recollection, asked him a couple of times if he would be interested.
However – for good or for ill – Neeson’s then-fiancee Natasha Richardson, with whom he was shooting the film Nell, said to him: “Liam, I want to tell you something: if you play James Bond, we’re not getting married.” Her rationale was a reasonable one. As Neeson said: “Come on, there’s all those gorgeous girls in various countries getting into bed and getting out of bed. I’m sure a lot of her decision-making was based on that.”
Clive Owen
There has been perhaps no actor so closely associated with not taking on the 007 role as Clive Owen. After his tuxedo-clad performance in the crime film Croupier, which became a cult hit, Owen’s suave, saturnine presence was believed to be a perfect fit for the relaunched James Bond. So certain was Hollywood that Owen would take the part that he even appeared in a cameo as “Nigel Boswell, Agent 006” in the Steve Martin Pink Panther film.
Yet he was never cast in the role of Bond, losing out to Daniel Craig, and it remains another intriguing speculation as to why he did not take the job. It has been suggested that, like Burton, he asked for a share of the profits and was turned down, or alternatively that he simply did not want to assume the typecasting associated with the role. In any case, Owen was able to declare in 2014 that “Bond was the best thing that never happened to me”, showing an absence of regrets.
Dominic West
Today, Dominic West is regarded as one of Britain’s most versatile actors and an entertainingly candid interviewee, forever beguiling journalists with unguarded remarks. However, one subject he has never been especially open about is why he did not play James Bond in 2005; it has been suggested that his audition was strong, but he did not wish to stand in the way of Daniel Craig.
He was characteristically amusing about the circumstances in which he attempted to get the part – “Apparently all of the other candidates were turning up in a tux – as if dressed in full-on James Bond garb. So I went to my audition in an old pair of jeans and a tatty T-shirt. I thought I’d try to be different and go for the nonchalant look” – and anyone who has seen him play the likes of McNulty in The Wire and Richard Burton in the drama Burton and Taylor will know that he has the smouldering charisma (as well as the humour) to pull off the role. Yet he’s only 56 still – might it not be impossible that he could have another crack at it? We shall see.
Christian Bale
Christian Bale might have taken on two of the most iconic roles in popular culture – those of Batman and (Patrick) Bateman – but he missed the chance to add a third “B” to the list when he turned down the 007 gig. Barbara Broccoli was sufficiently impressed by Bale’s performance as the murderous investment banker in American Psycho to suggest the Bond role was “his for the asking”, but Bale – an actor who has never played the Hollywood game without a conspicuous degree of reluctance – was not interested. He described the “very British” franchise as one that he had no interest in participating in, and loathed the Bond character, saying he represented “every despicable stereotype about England and British actors”.
For good measure, he declared, post-Bateman, “[I have] already played a serial killer”. Given what a nightmare for the studio and producers a reluctant Bond would have been, it’s probably a relief that Bale never gave in to Broccoli’s entreaties. But he would have been a fascinatingly angry, violent 007: so much for the 12A rating for his films, one imagines.
This feature was originally published in February 2023 and has been updated.
Sign up to Herald Premium Editor’s Picks, delivered straight to your inbox every Friday. Editor-in-Chief Murray Kirkness picks the week’s best features, interviews and investigations. Sign up for Herald Premium here.