Legislation for critical infrastructure cybersecurity past due

An expert says delaying the rollout of critical infrastructure legislation leaves New Zealanders at risk of the negative impacts of cyber-attacks.
Globally, cyber attacks on operational technology (OT) systems are rising, and the NZ companies that run critical infrastructure are underinvesting in cybersecurity, according to findings from recent research from US-based Palo Alto.
The research was funded by the cybersecurity firm and conducted by ABI Research. It surveyed 1,979 respondents worldwide, including from 50 businesses across various sectors in NZ.
It found that in the past year, 72% of NZ businesses had operational technology (OT) systems, which monitor or control industrial equipment targeted by cyber-attackers, and 30% were forced to shut down OT operations because of the attacks.
Palo Alto Australia and NZ regional chief security officer Alex Nehmy said attacks on critical infrastructure could cause serious problems for NZ's residents.
“An outage of the mobile phone system, which is critical infrastructure, can affect other industries in ways that we've never foreseen. Power outages can have critical impacts on entire countries … it can actually result in life or death.”
Discussion document
In June 2023, after Cyclone Gabrielle, the Government published a discussion document titled Strengthening the resilience of Aotearoa NZ's critical infrastructure system.
The document outlines ways to enhance the country’s critical infrastructure, including “extending New Zealand’s regulatory approach to cover cyber risks and imposing clear, consistent standards to protect critical assets against risks to information and operational technology”.
The Department of the Prime Minister and Cabinet’s (DPMC) website stated that it expected to launch a second round of consultation in the first half of this year, but it has not yet happened.
A representative of the DPMC told BusinessDesk: “The initial consultation has informed a series of policy proposals. The Government is currently considering next steps on how to take forward the work on critical infrastructure resilience.”
Legislative pressure
The document references Australia’s Security of Critical Infrastructure Act as a potential framework for NZ’s legislation.
Nehmy was the chief information security officer (CISO) for Australian lines operation SA Power Networks when the country introduced the act in 2018.
He said he saw how legislation encouraged companies to take cybersecurity more seriously.
“[Legislation] raised the awareness of the importance of securing critical infrastructure up to the executives of these organisations. Prior to the government passing this legislation and making it really visible and really public, organisations had somewhat under-invested, and executives maybe had this false sense of security.”
He said that while many of these systems were not connected to the internet ten years ago, that has since changed, and executives may be reticent to acknowledge that this has increased exposure to attacks.
“That attack surface that was once locked away in the four walls of an industrial environment is now expanded to the internet, to third-party organisations, and that has greatly increased the cybersecurity risk that these organisations face. Yet there is still a reluctance I would say for these organisations to deploy the level of cybersecurity that is necessary to address these risks, and even in some instances, they're probably hesitant to acknowledge that those risks exist.”
Sooner the better
Nehmy said delaying the implementation of regulation or legislation may be increasing the risk to NZ’s residents as relying on industry’s self-motivation may not be a reliable approach.
“Historically, when it's been left up to industry, the investment hasn't necessarily been there.”
He added that once organisations know their obligations, it will take them some time to catch up.
“Organisations will spend the next, let's say, half a dozen years raising their cybersecurity posture. And by the time that that has happened, the threats would have increased. Again, this is an arms race. And it really requires continual focus and continual investment to match the increase in threats every year.”
Proactive, not reactive
There were dozens of submissions from organisations on the document, varying in their level of support for the document's contents.
One recurring theme was that tighter regulation would increase business costs in an already low-margin environment.
Nehmy said that if a company wanted to provide critical infrastructure, ensuring it was secure was the cost of doing business.
He said that looking at global trends, this kind of legislation was inevitable in NZ, and companies would be better off starting to invest now than under regulatory pressure.
“It's always better to be proactive than reactive, and implementing the right cybersecurity for your organisation, and doing it your way, is much better than being forced and having this kind of knee-jerk compliance mindset.
“Just because you made a compliance framework doesn't necessarily mean that you're as secure as you need to be.”
