Is a levy on digital advertising the answer to the media's woes?

The impending closure of Newshub is yet another sign that all is not well for legacy media. (Image: NZME)
The impending closure of Newshub is yet another sign that all is not well for legacy media. (Image: NZME)

The impending closure of Newshub and job cuts at TVNZ are the latest signs of market failure in the news media, with pressure building on the government to intervene in the sector.

One plan to save the industry, Labour’s Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill, looks doomed to failure, raising urgent questions about the credible alternatives.

National has for months signalled its opposition to the online news bill, with Melissa Lee – now media minister – labelling it before the election as a “tax”.

The bill, which would force tech platforms into mandatory bargaining with news publishers if they don’t agree to commercial deals, also looks increasingly outdated.

Aggressive approach a disaster

The fair digital news legislation is modelled on Australian and Canadian approaches to regulating big tech, though both countries have ultimately fallen short of their goals to make the giant foreign platforms pay for the long-term future of news.

Canada’s more aggressive approach, dubbed a “link tax”, has been a disaster, prompting Meta to block news on its platforms in the country.

Google has made similar threats, engaging in a drawn-out dispute with Canadian lawmakers. Smaller publishers have suffered in the crossfire.

Australia’s more flexible law, introduced in 2021, enjoyed more success initially, forcing Meta into deals with a host of local publishers, including News Corp.

In the years since, however, Meta has wound down its global news initiative and last week announced it was ending its Australian deals.

Simpler way

With the Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill, if passed, likely to result in Meta blocking news in New Zealand and Google threatening to “reassess” its business model in NZ, the legislation looks better suited to 2021 than 2024.

With National and Act already opposed, its future doesn’t look bright.

Yet many in the media believe there is a simpler way to give journalism a financial boost, benefit from the activity of the multinational tech firms in NZ, and avoid hitting the taxpayer in the pocket: a levy on all digital advertising in NZ.

The idea has been championed by Better Public Media (BPM) for years.

The charitable trust, which advocates for stronger public interest journalism, believes policymakers can support the news sector and benefit from the economic activity of the digital platforms without the need for legal disputes.

How a levy could work

In theory, BPM argues, a levy would be charged at the point of sale to all digital advertisers in NZ. Every digital platform selling ads would have to charge the levy.

The money would be collected and given to an arm’s-length entity such as NZ on Air or a newly created entity like Apra, the independent organisation that manages musicians’ royalties in NZ.

The entity in charge would channel the money back into journalism projects, much like the role NZ on Air played in the Public Interest Journalism Fund (PIJF).

Unlike the much-maligned PIJF, the money wouldn’t come from government coffers. Like the PIJF, it would target specific public interest journalism projects and roles, such as court reporters and trainees.

More effective

BPM chair Peter Thompson believes a levy would be a more effective way for New Zealanders to benefit from the omnipresent big tech groups.

“Digital advertising is about a $1.8 billion market in New Zealand. A 1% levy on advertising would bring in $18 million a year, about what the PIJF handed out each year. Put on a 3% levy, and you’re up to $54m a year, at the higher end of the Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill’s revenue estimates.

“All companies that collect digital advertising would pay something into the pot, but they’ll get a lot more back, with interest, if they are news content creators. A small levy on those that benefit commercially from the media could compensate for the market failure of parts of the media.”

He added: “It would be a far more elegant solution than the extremely complicated and ultimately unenforceable Fair Digital News Bargaining Bill, which would see news publishers engaged in protracted legal arguments.”

Alternatives explored

Supporters of the advertising levy describe it as a “broad brush” idea that “doesn’t single out” individual tech firms.

According to sources close to Google and Meta, executives at the internet titans have privately expressed support for the idea.

The sudden decision by Warner Bros Discovery (WBD) to shut down Newshub, TVNZ’s ongoing newsroom cuts and the poor outlook for the online news bill have prompted academics and media figures to explore alternatives to Labour’s legislation.

Koi Tū: The Centre for Informed Futures is writing a paper on the available policy options. A former prime ministerial chief science adviser, Sir Peter Gluckman, former NZ Herald editor-in-chief Gavin Ellis and journalist Peter Bale will work on the report.

Ellis says Koi Tū will explore a range of options, but he also supports a form of levy targeting the NZ revenues of the tech groups rather than the entire ad market.

“A levy on all advertising would affect the legacy media, but you could introduce a levy for the platforms that appropriate content,” he says. “Given current circumstances, that’s probably a better way of raising money for the industry.”

Like Thompson, Ellis believes Labour’s law is impractical.

“These platforms can’t be relied upon to bargain equitably, and with many smaller outlets, they won’t bargain at all. A pursuit of this bill, in its current form, is a hiding to nothing.”

American officials “not supportive”

A revenue levy has been explored before. Cabinet papers from December 2022 reveal that the then media minister, Willie Jackson, considered a levy on digital platforms’ NZ revenue, which would be distributed by a “central authority” such as NZ on Air.

However, Ministry for Culture and Heritage (MCH) officials warned a flat levy on NZ revenue risked being viewed as a digital service tax, with American officials “not supportive” of the idea.

A levy would have to be implemented “in a manner consistent with NZ’s existing trade obligations”, officials added.

Thompson says a market-wide ad charge would be fairer than a levy on Meta and Google’s turnover.

“If you build a bill around arbitrarily taxing two companies because they’re rich, that’s rather problematic logic in terms of public policy,” he argues.

“An ad levy effectively taxes these companies in proportion to their revenues. The more digital advertising they win, the more money the levy will accrue. You could even extend it to streamers to help the local screen industry.”

More a copyright issue

Proponents of levies believe that the other major challenge facing the news media, artificial intelligence (AI) chatbots "scraping" content, is best served with a dedicated AI regulatory framework.

Ellis describes the AI conundrum as “a complex and developing area of law involving a form of technology whose potential is only starting to be understood”. Thompson believes the AI challenge is more of a copyright issue.

As the clamour for media policy grows with each round of redundancies, Melissa Lee says no decision will be taken on the online news bill or alternatives until the select committee reports back in May.

“Everything’s up for consideration,” she told BusinessDesk. “There's a select committee process; people make submissions. We need to look at all of that once the submission process has finished.”

Lee said she was “shocked” by last week’s WBD announcement and had not expected the US business to pull out of NZ news.

“From the way they were talking and moving, it looked like they were going to go fully digital, not cut news and local production. My thoughts were, ‘Wow, this is big’. I was a journalist once, and I feel for them.”

'Willie Jackson had the opportunity'

She dismissed criticism from Jackson, her predecessor, who said the coalition was “missing in action” over the news crisis.

“Willie Jackson had the opportunity to pass the bill and put the law in place before his term in government ended. His government had six years to do what he thinks I should be doing. I've only been in the role for three months, and I'm trying to fix it.”

It looks inevitable that a fix is required and likely that the online news bill won’t be the answer. Many people are convinced that an ad levy offers the neatest solution.

Either way, the government must get creative and move quickly if it wants to remedy the broken news media.