Why sacking Nash was not the obvious option for NZ First – Heather du Plessis-Allan


It is weird that New Zealand First sacked Stuart Nash this week.
Let’s first establish that it was a sacking, not a resignation. Nash is not a happy man. He feels unfairly treated.
He may have a point. He called his Napier rival Katie Nimon “lazy”. Hardly the worst thing anyone’s said about a political rival. He suggested she took too much maternity leave away from Parliament. A fair opinion to hold. Dame Jacinda Ardern took six weeks. Julie-Anne Genter took 12 weeks for the birth of her first child. Nimon took 24-plus.
An electorate MP is not a normal job. There is no replacement advocating for Napier when the MP is absent. For six months, her voters did not have her advocacy.
As her employers, we are entitled to discuss the length of her, and future MPs’, leave.
Nash’s lingering resentment over his punishment is not the sentiment of a man who willingly resigned. It is the sentiment of a man given the ultimatum of resign or be sacked.
So, let’s call it for what it really is. It’s a sacking.
It’s weird because it was not the most obvious option for NZ First.
This is a party that has built much of its appeal on being a bulwark against what its leader calls the “snivelling wokesters”. It is a party that constantly rails against the mainstream media.
The most obvious option, then, when the snivelling wokesters and mainstream media melted down and came for their man was actually to give them the middle finger and defend Nash’s right to say what he likes.
The most obvious option was not to cave within less than 12 hours.

That Winston Peters chose that option was a surprise. Especially when he has in recent weeks defended Shane Jones referring to Indian migrants as a “butter chicken tsunami”. Especially when he has in recent days defended Jones making an oral sex reference about the Prime Minister’s enthusiasm for the visiting Indian PM.
But the mathematics didn’t stack up for Nash.
There are many times more women voters than Indian voters in New Zealand. Nash was already on his last chance for his crude description of what a woman is and his aggro texts to the Trade Minister. And NZ First now has two heirs-apparent: Michael Laws and Jones. Nash is at best surplus to requirements and at worst a threat that allowed itself to be eliminated.
And so, he was eliminated. The political risk his comments created was nuked. But that move carries some political risk too. Peters’ near-instant capitulation must shake the faith of those anti-woke voters drawn to him as their defender. Not much of a defender, it turns out, when it doesn’t suit him.
National’s overreaction to the comments also carries some risk. It must be remembered that it is ultimately National that orchestrated Nash’s demise.
It was former National minister Chris Finlayson who revealed Nash’s private text on his personal podcast. It was National which then went ballistic about it, rolling out its big guns to declare what a sexist Nash was. Each made a point of sounding more outraged than the other.

National also has a problem with women voters. And so, National went extra hard battling on behalf of the sisterhood.
But the risk is that not all National voters necessarily love the idea of a gig worker like an MP spending more than six months of a three-year contract away from the office. And the greater risk is that not all of its voters love National cosplaying the culture war warrior.
Perhaps it is the nervous energy of a close-run election causing everyone to lose their bearings, but this has been a bizarre performance for everyone involved.
Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.