What we know about why everything seems to be breaking at once

Miriam Waldvogel
What we know about why everything seems to be breaking at once
Passengers wait at boarding gates at Ronald Reagan Washington National Airport in Washington DC after the Federal Aviation Administration issued a ground stop at all US airports due to a communications problem. Photo / Zina Desmazes, AFP

Experts say the outages don’t seem to be connected. Everyone wants answers.

It’s a long list. Microsoft’s Outlook emails, US air traffic control, JPMorgan Chase and United Airlines were among the numerous high-profile systems that have had outages in the past week.

The interruptions snarled workdays, upended travel plans and have driven speculation about an IT doomsday.

The wave of outages comes after a period the cybersecurity world called “Black October” for the number of significant vulnerabilities that were disclosed – and then fixed – by security researchers, many by AI tools.

Many of the companies and institutions whose technology went down have said there’s no evidence of AI-driven attacks or foul play involved. US Government officials and experts too have said the outages appear unrelated. But people – including some lawmakers and media figures – have speculated nonetheless, and called for more information.

“The American people can see everything happening with these service outages, and they feel like they’re not getting the whole story,” Republican Senator Rick Scott said in a post on X. “You can’t blame anybody for that. I’m a member of Congress, and I feel that way! ... These companies and federal agencies need to be fully transparent about what’s going on.”

US Secretary of State Marco Rubio acknowledged on Tuesday (Wednesday NZT) that the outages had made people nervous, in remarks to reporters during President Donald Trump’s visit to Manila. But Rubio said that the US Government had “zero evidence” that the events are connected.

“We see no indications that these things are interrelated, one event to the other, or that they’re the work of malign actors,” he said.

The episodes underline a widespread reliance on highly connected and complex systems where a failure in one part of the network can easily spread, experts said.

“It sure does look like all these events are connected, but all the available evidence suggests that they’re not,” said Chris Krebs, who ran the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency during the first Trump administration, in a Tuesday morning appearance on CBS.

“Take a beat. Everybody just needs to chill out for a second.”

The messaging from US Government officials has been mixed. Appearing on Fox News on Monday night, Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said cybersecurity officials had told him the various events were unrelated – then quickly undermined that.

“One guy that’s very smart with tech, he asked to not mention his name ... he says, ‘I believe it’s the SI,’” he said, using the Trump administration’s preferred term for artificial intelligence.

“Nothing points to it being connected, other than what the guy that leads the technology that – I really wish I could mention his name – that was talking to me and briefing me on this, probably about three hours ago,” he said.

The Department of Homeland Security did not immediately return a request for comment.

AI: The good, the bad and the scary

The disruptions come at a time when the number of significant reported bugs has exploded, motivating changes to fix them. But the fixes could themselves cause problems down the line due to the complexity of software systems.

Security experts have warned that sophisticated AI tools could help supercharge hacking attempts, even as AI capabilities can also help ensure systems are more secure.

US Senator Mark Warner, the top Democrat on the Senate Select Committee on Intelligence, said in a statement that AI-discovered vulnerabilities had put “enormous pressure” on governments and companies to institute fixes, “putting tremendous strain on systems that weren’t built to handle that pace of change”.

“While we still need to get to the bottom of these incidents, the evidence so far points toward legitimate efforts to secure our systems, not malicious activity,” Warner added.

Security researchers announced on Tuesday that they had used AI to uncover a severe issue in the programming language Java, which is used in the systems of most of the Fortune 500 companies.

Las week's Microsoft outage swept the globe, taking the company’s products offline in at least 74 countries and territories, according to the monitoring site Downdetector. Photo / Getty Images
Las week's Microsoft outage swept the globe, taking the company’s products offline in at least 74 countries and territories, according to the monitoring site Downdetector. Photo / Getty Images

While there is no indication that AI was involved in any of these recent incidents, cybersecurity officials have still been on the lookout for vulnerabilities. The FBI last week – before the latest spate of outages – issued a warning for an open-source AI platform called ARTEX that it said threat actors had used to automate various phases of cyberattacks at “machine speed”.

The apparent causes of the incidents are numerous, some from seemingly obscure sources. Microsoft said it had brought online new servers before the Outlook outage, and United said a brief disruption in departures on Monday was due to a tech issue but not a cybersecurity one. After the nationwide ground stop last week that lasted more than four hours, US federal aviation officials blamed the replacement of old copper wire used to route network traffic.

Still, the outages have put people on edge.

“I’m wondering the same thing: What’s happening? I’m checking my bank account with a little bit of worry. And what I would say to the White House is, transparency is key,” former White House press secretary Karoline Leavitt said Monday morning on Fox News. “I think, again, the White House should just address it directly with the American people.”

More than 18,000 flights in the United States were cancelled between Friday and Sunday, forcing people to sleep in airports or jettison travel plans altogether. Apple on Tuesday reported issues with various products, including the app store and sign-in for iCloud accounts. The company said in a statement that an internal update had “caused some outages” and said it was not a cyberattack. A key internal communications system for classified messages run by the National Security Agency was temporarily out of commission on Tuesday.

The string of outages indicates that people need to do a better job of understanding how their critical systems work, said Anjana Rajan, a former Biden administration official and CEO of the cybersecurity company Atalanta.

“We’re asking too many questions about who did this, rather than, ‘do I even understand what my systems are doing under normal, abnormal or hostile conditions’,” she said. “When you start to have these really complex, sprawling, software-defined systems that are all interconnected, it’s very hard to understand them.”

On Monday, an issue affecting about 150 major websites, including those of airlines and retailers, stemmed from a third-party marketing website that appeared to allow hackers to inject computer code of their choosing. But vulnerability and harm are not the same thing. The hackers appeared to take little advantage of it, said Scott Helme, the security researcher who uncovered it. The sites all stayed up.

“I am staggered at how little the attackers here have used the ability that they had at their disposal,” Helme said. “That’s a great thing for the victims, but there was just something strange here with how little they’ve done.”

– Cleve R. Wootson Jr contributed to this report

Sign up to Herald Premium Editor’s Picks, delivered straight to your inbox every Friday. Editor-in-Chief Murray Kirkness picks the week’s best features, interviews and investigations. Sign up for Herald Premium here.