Opinion

My company owes tax. How will that affect my divorce? - The Ex-Files

Opinion by
Jeremy Sutton is a barrister and family lawyer at Bastion Chambers.
Personal tax penalties may be treated as separate debt after a separation. Photo / 123rf
Personal tax penalties may be treated as separate debt after a separation. Photo / 123rf

Q: My wife and I have separated after being married for 20 years and are dividing our relationship property. I am an electrician, and about 15 years ago I set up my own business. I now employ seven electricians. The company has become very busy and profitable. My ex-wife has worked for the business for the last 10 years. She takes all the customer phone calls and inquiries and schedules the work. I handle the financial side of things.

I am ashamed to admit the company has not declared all income earned in the last five years. I wanted to use the extra cash to acquire some new company vehicles and undertake some renovations on our family home. I have been notified by the Inland Revenue Department that it intends to undertake an audit in the next month. The IRD will almost certainly uncover this unreported income and, therefore, in addition to the tax that is payable on the company’s income, there will be substantial interest and penalties.

When valuing the company for relationship property purposes, should the unpaid tax as well as any interest and penalties be taken into account in assessing the value of the company’s shares?

Also, my ex-wife’s solicitor has signalled that she intends to make a claim for unequal sharing of the value of the company on the basis that there are “extraordinary circumstances” because of the unpaid tax. What does she mean by this?

Unpaid tax

A: Yes, the unpaid tax and any interest and penalties will be taken into account in determining the value of the company shares. This is because those debts belong to the company; they are not personal debts which can be categorised as relationship or separate debts under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976.

Unequal division

The avenue for your ex-wife to challenge responsibility for those debts is through section 13 of the act which is the claim her lawyer has signalled.

Usually all relationship property owned by parties to a relationship is divided equally. However, under section 13 the court can order an unequal division of relationship property where there are extraordinary circumstances which would make equal sharing repugnant to justice.

While the threshold under section 13 is high, there is case law to support your ex-wife’s claim.

Tax issues

In a case where one party had no knowledge of company and personal tax debts, interest and penalties a section 13 claim succeeded. The court found the impact of the tax omissions on the property pool was a “major one” and the failure to correctly declare company transactions lifted the case out of the ordinary and into the realm of the extraordinary. The outcome was a 30:70 division. You have similar exposure.

It is important to note, if you also have undeclared personal income which results in IRD claiming interest and penalties then the interest and penalties could be classified as separate debt for which you would be solely responsible.

In the same case referred to above, when determining the classification of the husband’s personal tax debts the court found that while the core tax debt was a relationship debt, the interest and penalties were the result of gross carelessness by the husband (of which the wife had no knowledge) and fell within the definition of personal debt. The husband was solely responsible for payment of the interest and penalties.

In some cases where there has been tax evasion, criminal charges will be laid. If you have not already done so, you should consider instructing a tax lawyer to assist you as to how best to manage the situation.

Summary

You need to consider any taxation issues in any relationship property settlement where a business is involved. I recommend you get advice from an accountant or tax specialist.

Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.