Analysis

Inside Economics: Is a short sharp crash better than a slow correction?

Liam Dann
Analysis by
Liam Dann, Business Editor at Large for New Zealand’s Herald, works as a writer, columnist, radio commentator and as a presenter and producer of videos and podcasts.
Is orderly market correction then measured rational growth really for the betterment of investors, a reader asks? Image / 123rf
Liam Dann and Tamsyn Parker explore why NZ’s recovery still feels tough, how housing is holding us back, and what a weaker dollar means for your wallet.

Welcome to Inside Economics. Every week, I take a deeper dive into some of the more left-field economic news you may have missed. To sign up for my weekly newsletter, click here. If you have a burning question about the quirks or intricacies of economics send it to liam.dann@nzherald.co.nz or leave a message in the comments section.

Better to burn out or fade away

Hi Liam,

I love your commentary; keep up the good work. I do take slight issue with one of your comments, though.

That is the hope you express for orderly market correction and then measured rational growth, for the betterment of investors, including KiwiSaver. That sounds laudable at first hearing, like the sort of thing European central planners aim at, with dismal results, compared to more free-flowing economies. The result is slow stagnation, and it turns out not to be for the betterment of investors, or indeed any citizens of Europe.

The AI transition will not be orderly unless it is regulated, and then it will be suboptimal in improving wealth and people’s lives in the medium term.

Why not wish for investors to:

  • enter into a period of increased volatility knowingly, expecting it in both AI and non-AI companies and shares, as creative destruction rolls forward;
  • that if they aren’t expert, they are well diversified;
  • that they invest in risk assets with a long-term view;
  • that we, as a country, find ways to mitigate short-term effects and help in people transitions?

Regards

Dave H

A: Thanks, Dave.

Maybe it is better for markets to crash out and then recover relatively quickly than it is to go through a longer, more stable period of adjustment.

Your point takes me back to one of my favourite economists, Joseph Schumpeter.

Writing in the 1940s, he popularised the idea of “creative destruction”: the constant process by which new technologies and firms displace old ones.

His point was that big slumps and crashes weren’t a side effect of capitalism but an important feature of it.

Schumpeter argued that innovations arrive in clusters rather than in a steady and orderly flow, which is why booms form around them and why they end in painful meltdowns.

Because innovations cluster, booms and busts are part of the process. A breakthrough attracts imitators and credit, the boom overshoots, and then a shake-out follows as weaker firms fail and resources are redeployed.

That was, for example, a good description of the railways boom and bust in the 1840s, the automotive and electrical boom of the 1920s that crashed in 1929, the internet in the late 1990s, and – probably – the AI boom.

My hope – as per last week’s column – that we see a slow, orderly correction to the AI bubble looks possible.

But I also argued this was the less likely scenario.

Drawing on Schumpeter, I also think there is something intrinsic to boom and bust cycles.

In my view, some of that is simply that markets aren’t always rational. They run on human emotions – fear and greed.

So I often ponder how much better things would be if the ups and downs were more moderate.

But I take your point that a shorter, sharper shock might be better for everyone.

Creative destruction is messy and painful.

When they have become unrealistic and inflated by irrational investor greed, prices need to fall so capital can move to where it’s better used.

Sometimes economists use the forest fire analogy to describe creative destruction.

After a fire has raged through, the land is cleared for new growth to take hold.

I should say I like your four wishes, and I’d happily adopt them.

Let’s hope investors go in well warned about volatility and risks.

Let’s hope they (or our KiwiSaver providers) are well diversified.

Let’s hope they take a long-term view to investment in risk assets.

And yes, as a country, let’s look for ways to cushion short-term effects and help people through transitions.

I’m keen to hear what readers think...

Housing market malaise

If you want a good example of an unhelpful market malaise, look no further than the New Zealand housing market.

There was boom and bust initially; prices soared in late 2002 and through 2021 on cheap credit, as the Covid lockdown did nothing to hamper the property investment sector.

In 2022 the market reversed; there was a sizeable initial slump with prices falling 16% to the middle of 2023.

Nobody panicked as it was (rightly) seen as a reversal from the Covid boom, and overall prices remain elevated.

Since then, things have tracked more or less sideways, with some ups and plenty of downs coming in a series of subtle incremental fits and starts.

But when you put it all together and factor in inflation, the real value destruction is quite remarkable: more than 30% in Auckland and 40% in Wellington.

Part of the problem with the housing market – and a big part of the broader cost equation – is time.

The extended period without growth makes things much worse than a nominal fall in value.

There is the inflation effect mentioned above. In a time of relatively high inflation the value of a dollar weakens significantly over time.

But there are also flow-on effects to the economy as property-adjacent businesses suffer from the extended malaise.

After the Covid boom and bust, house prices have tracked sideways. Photo / 123rf
After the Covid boom and bust, house prices have tracked sideways. Photo / 123rf

This is all the service sector businesses in Auckland related to property. Builders, roofers, landscapers, real estate agents, interior decorators ... the list goes on.

That’s all activity with a direct link. But beyond that, most economists believe there is a wealth effect that boosts consumer spending more broadly when they feel their net worth is being inflated by the value of their largest asset.

As we head into the sixth year of this property downturn, you have to wonder if the economic damage it is doing will ultimately be greater than if all the value destruction had happened in a much shorter, sharper crash.

That would have garnered much greater headlines. It would have been historic and would probably have caused more problems for our banking sector.

But it would have provoked a strong policy response from the Reserve Bank.

We’d have had a very bad year for business liquidations and mortgagee sales.

Perhaps, though, the final numbers might have been smaller than what we’ll end up seeing as more and more businesses and home owners lose the war of attrition in this downturn.

Two steps forward ...

The housing market and consumer spending both took a hit in October as fuel prices spiked again.

But the good news is it looks like the economy kept growing.

BNZ says its Production of Manufacturing and Production of Services Index (PMI and PSI) both stayed in expansion and that suggests the economic recovery is broadening.

“The positive PMI/PSI October results are arguably better than they look given the headwinds of political uncertainty prevailing ahead of the November 7 election, recent interest rate hikes, and resurgent fuel prices through September and October,” BNZ senior economist Doug Steel wrote.

“This suggests there is room for further improvement if the clear drop in fuel prices underway in November extends, as the drop in global prices indicate is possible, and when the current period of post-election political limbo clears.”

Manufacturing has been (very) slowly but steadily improving for a long time. Last week’s survey showed the 16th month of expansion in a row.

The services sector has been doing it a lot tougher.

But the latest reading for October was 51.7 (where a reading above 50 indicates the sector is generally expanding, and a reading below 50 indicates the sector is in contraction).

This was up 0.8 points from 50.9 in September, and the highest reading in more than three and a half years, Steel said.

It was the fifth month of expansion in a row.

The service sector matters because it is a big employer, especially in urban areas like Auckland and Wellington, which have been struggling.

Employment data tends to lag by several months, but this reading should provide some confidence that the labour market will start to improve in 2027.

“The robust PMI and PSI activity indicators are consistent with our forecast of around 2% GDP growth in 2026. It is reasonable growth although it remains uneven with other indicators mixed,” Steel said.

Inflation outlook

We got the latest food, energy, transport and accommodation prices on Tuesday in the Stats NZ Selected Price Index.

It landed much as economists expected, which wasn’t great.

Fuel prices jumped about 11% in October.

Diesel was up 71% for the full year, petrol was up 38%.

That’s prompted some ugly forecasts for annual inflation to the end of the fourth quarter. Both ANZ and ASB now see it hitting 4.4%. Westpac and BNZ are picking 4.3%.

“We remain concerned that inflation over 2027 could prove slow to recede despite favourable base effects,” ASB’s Mark Smith wrote.

Large second-quarter increases were set to drop out of the annual comparison for the second quarter 2027, he noted.

“New Zealand fuel prices have been high for a concerted period, with risks that this follows through into wider wage and price setting.”

An NZ dollar sitting at 17-year lows (on a Trade Weighted Index basis) and around 55 US cents would not be helpful for containing costs and imported inflation, he said.

There’s no doubt inflation remains the dark cloud hanging over our recovery hopes.

Keep watching that oil price!

Don’t forget to check out the Herald’s new podcast, The Economy of Everything, with Liam Dann and Tamsyn Parker – thanks to CMC Markets.

Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts.

He joined the Herald in 2003. To sign up to his weekly newsletter, click on your user profile at nzherald.co.nz and select “My newsletters”.

For a step-by-step guide, click here. If you have a burning question about the quirks or intricacies of economics send it to liam.dann@nzherald.co.nz or leave a message in the comments section.