Data shows properties resold at a loss highest in 14 years during September quarter

The proportion of properties resold at a loss in the third quarter was the highest since 2012, according to Cotality. Photo / 123rf
Independent economist Tony Alexander says a record number of houses sold at a loss in New Zealand in Q3, while Australia's market has slumped. Video / Ryan Bridge TODAY

The proportion of New Zealand properties resold at a loss reached its highest level in 14 years, figures from Cotality show, but one expert is warning the situation is “much worse”.

Cotality New Zealand’s Pain and Gain Report revealed 15.8% of properties sold in the September quarter did so for less than their previous purchase price – the highest level since the third quarter of 2012.

The median loss was $60,000.

Meanwhile, 84.2% of residential properties were resold for a gross profit, with a median gain of $270,000.

Time in the market remained a key factor, with properties resold at a loss having been owned for a median of 4.5 years, compared with 10.4 years for those resold for a gain.

Property Investors Federation advocacy manager Matt Ball said the figures are just the gross numbers and do not take inflation and other costs into account.

The situation was “much worse” than the numbers suggest, as many more people are selling at a loss, he told Newstalk ZB’s Early Edition.

Ball said a home was purchased in his neighbourhood in 2019 for $1.6 million and sold earlier this year for $1.725m, but has lost money despite showing a profit on paper.

“If you look at its inflation-adjusted value, that’s $2.1 million. So in reality, this house would have needed to sell for over $2.1 million just to break even, and it actually made a loss of nearly $400,000.”

Cotality NZ chief property economist Kelvin Davidson said owners who bought more recently had generally been more exposed to the market downturn.

“Most buyers would not have purchased with the intention of selling again so soon, but circumstances might have worked against them, such as a family or job change, or financial strain brought on by previously sharp rises in mortgage rates,” he said.

Davidson said the deterioration in resale conditions remained gradual, with more than four in five property resellers still making a gross profit.

“The share of profitable resales has taken four to five years to ease from around 99% at the peak to 84.2% now,” he said.

“During the Global Financial Crisis, it fell much faster, from about 98% in mid-2007 to around 80% by early 2009.

“Overall, the latest figures are not a sign of a fresh collapse. Instead, they reflect the large falls in property values already seen, with more sellers progressively just having to make a deal in softer market conditions as each quarter passes.”

In Auckland, one in four (25.5%) properties were resold for a loss, followed by Wellington (20.4%), Hamilton (19.1%), Tauranga (15.3%), Christchurch (7.5%) and Dunedin (6.9%).

Almost half (48%) of apartments resold in the third quarter changed hands for less than their previous purchase price, compared with 22.5% of townhouses and 13.4% of standalone houses.

“Population falls and economic uncertainty have weighed on Wellington, while Auckland has seen a steady rise in housing supply. The relative weakness of apartments has also affected both markets,” Davidson said.

OneRoof editor Owen Vaughan said its own analysis of resale profit and loss in the housing market this year highlights much the same.

“The regions most exposed to the downturn have generally been those that experienced the biggest Covid-era house price booms, particularly Wellington and Auckland,” he said.

“By contrast, Southland, Canterbury and much of Otago have retained relatively high resale profitability.

“How long sellers have held on to their properties also matters. Our data shows loss-making properties were typically held for around four to six years, highlighting the risks faced by sellers who bought during the Covid-era boom.”

  • Stay ahead with the latest market moves, corporate updates, and economic insights by subscribing to our Business newsletter – your essential weekly round-up of all the business news you need.