Can I get my ex to pay half our daughter’s orthodontic work? - The Ex-Files

THE FACTS
- A Family Court judge may find orthodontic treatment in Zara’s best interests, considering her self-esteem.
- The court could order the ex-husband to pay half the cost of braces.
- Zara’s tattoo request is less pressing; she can decide independently at age 18.
My husband and I separated several years ago. We have two daughters, aged 11 and 13. Recently my ex-husband and I have been at loggerheads regarding two issues affecting our 13-year-old, Zara: whether she should have braces (and who should pay), and whether we should allow her to get a small tattoo on the back of her shoulder.
Q: Zara’s top teeth are crooked. She has become self-conscious about this and she now smiles with her mouth closed. My ex-husband thinks crooked teeth are a minor cosmetic issue and braces are unnecessary. Unsurprisingly, he is unwilling to contribute to the cost of orthodontic treatment. As a single mother I do not have the funds to cover the cost on my own. Can my ex-husband be required to pay half?
In regards to the tattoo, Zara has been persistently asking for permission for nearly a year. I am not thrilled at the prospect, but it would be a very small tattoo of her favourite instrument (a piano) in a spot that is usually covered by clothing. She has saved money from her newspaper run that she could use to fund it. Again, my husband is totally opposed to the tattoo. He says she is too young.
Braces
Whether your daughter should have braces to straighten her teeth is a guardianship decision. As you and your husband are both joint guardians, you will need to reach agreement on this issue before proceeding with treatment. If you cannot secure your husband’s agreement (preferably in writing), you will need to seek permission from the Family Court.

In determining whether Zara should have braces, the court will consider what is in her best interests. The court will appoint a lawyer to ascertain Zara’s views. At 13, her views would carry significant weight – that is, the judge would give serious regard to her wishes.
My view is that a Family Court judge would be likely to find that the orthodontic treatment is in Zara’s best interests and would grant an order permitting you to arrange the treatment. The issue is affecting her self-esteem, and she wishes to have the treatment done. It is likely the orthodontic treatment would be more difficult and costly as she gets older (and it would be worthwhile you submitting evidence from an experienced dentist to testify to this).
If you do proceed with an application in the Family Court for a guardianship direction regarding braces, you could seek an order as part of this application that your ex-husband meet half the cost of the orthodontic treatment. The court has wide powers to make any order relating to the matter that it considers “proper”. An alternative avenue would be to apply for a departure from the formula assessment relating to child support, seeking an increase in the amount of child support your ex-husband pays.
Tattoo
My view is that this matter is less pressing and would not be worth pursing through the courts. Your daughter is still young and the tattoo is a display of self-expression that she may change her mind about. Once she is 18, she will be free to get a tattoo without her father’s consent.

Generally, in respect of any guardianship issue, the judge will exercise their discretion to determine what is in the best interests of the child in the circumstances. It is therefore not possible to predict with absolute certainty the outcome of the court’s decision in any case.
Should you decide to pursue court proceedings, you would need to undertake Family Dispute Resolution before you file an application seeking a guardianship order from the Family Court. This would involve you and your ex-husband meeting with a neutral mediator to attempt to resolve the issues by agreement. It can be effective in resolving many parenting disagreements out of court.
Catch up on the debates that dominated the week by signing up to our Opinion newsletter – a weekly round-up of our best commentary.