Business leader Guy Haddleton urges Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins to form a grand coalition

Guy Haddleton, New Zealand entrepreneur and investor. Photo / supplied.
The former SAS soldier has built billion-dollar businesses and believes NZ needs to think bigger about its economic future. Guy Haddleton joins Liam Dann on Money Talks.

Outspoken business leader Guy Haddleton is calling on Christopher Luxon and Chris Hipkins to form a grand coalition.

“Here’s my question for Chris Luxon and Chris Hipkins. Before you start negotiating with the smaller parties, why don’t you sit down with each other?” he said.

“Not just for a photograph, but a serious conversation about how National and Labour would govern together around a long-term national plan, building ambition?”

The billionaire founder of tech companies Adaytum and Anaplan has been vocal about New Zealand’s poor economic performance in the past decade and says the country needs stability and a long-term plan.

That’s a formula he doesn’t believe can be achieved with a “business as usual” approach to MMP.

“What’s happened so far is that we’ve got a potential coalition on either side that is going to be very fragile and is unlikely to navigate our way through the next three years with confidence if there’s global uncertainty,” Haddleton said.

The weekend’s tight election result, at a time of global uncertainty, meant the time had come for the two major parties to work together, he said.

Haddleton conceded that the idea might sound “crazy” to some.

“I know a lot of people of both parties would say, ' What the devil’s going on here?‘” he said.

But “Chris and Chippy” had both called for compromise, he said.

“I am asking them to explore the biggest one available. Tell us what you would build together, and what you would give up.”

The numbers make it possible, Haddleton said.

National and Labour had 58.6% of the party vote and 78 seats collectively, he said.

New Zealand was at a critical point in its economic journey and could not afford “more of the same,” he said.

“It is probably radical for New Zealand, absolutely.

“We need radical thinking.”

But globally there were precedents.

In Germany, Angela Merkel had faced this problem in 2005, 2009 and then 2013 to 2021, he said.

“She decided to put the centre right and the centre left together. Ireland did the same. Denmark did exactly the same.”

In 2022, the Danish Prime Minister had a centre-left coalition, but she argued that it should be cross-party because they were going through difficult times, he said.

“So it’s not really a radical approach; it’s common sense.

“Why must the smallest partners always have the final say? Why does the tail wag the dog all the time?”

If John Key and Helen Clark were in this position today, Key would be contemplating how they could put together a government that made sense for everybody “rather than working on the fringes of the left and the right to mutual disadvantage”.

At the Herald’s pre-election Future of New Zealand debate, Haddleton grabbed attention by using real pizzas to illustrate his economic approach.

“We argue endlessly about how to cut the pizza,” he said. “I want a bigger pizza, a bigger slice for every household, and New Zealanders owning more of the oven, the businesses, infrastructure and intellectual property that make it.”

Haddleton said he wanted to see a bipartisan target of 2.5% growth a year in real output per person, over the economic cycle.

“That is a target, not a forecast. Not growth puffed up by rising prices or by adding people. Then measure what households actually feel: median incomes, progress for lower-income families, and the cost of housing, power and healthcare.”

Haddleton said he also wanted to see the three-year political cycle addressed, as governments needed more time to implement long-term strategic policies.

“Changing the three-year term needs 75% of Parliament or a referendum.

“National, Labour, Act, the Greens and NZ First all broadly backed a four-year term, and the referendum was still shelved in February because there was not time to organise it. A broad government could run that case properly.”

Liam Dann is business editor-at-large for the New Zealand Herald. He is a senior writer and columnist, and also presents and produces videos and podcasts. He joined the Herald in 2003.

  • Stay ahead with the latest market moves, corporate updates, and economic insights by subscribing to our Business newsletter – your essential weekly round-up of all the business news you need.