
Senior equity strategists at investment banks are adept at spotting trends and patterns, which can help them to call market tops and bottoms – or at least help their clients calibrate risk – as they have the experience of several past market cycles behind them.
It is therefore fascinating to read just how many are reacting to, and recoiling from, the activity at a US-listed micro-cap stock.
Allbirds began life as a maker of sustainable wool sports shoes and trainers in New Zealand. It floated on the Nasdaq in late 2021, and the share price initially doubled to give the company a stock market capitalisation of US$4 billion ($6.7b).
By the start of this month, after nearly US$450 million of after-tax losses, missed profit forecasts and sliding sales, that valuation had slipped to US$22m. The company then sold the shoe business for all of US$39m and – here is the rub – renamed itself Newbird AI, with a new plan to provide silicon chips, data centres and AI infrastructure.
The company may have had zero experience in any of these areas, but the share price rose nearly six-fold on the announcement.
This episode clearly reminds experienced market students of prior periods when companies used a name change and a strategic review to goose their share price, only for the stock to prove just as big a turkey as it did in its prior incarnation.
The so-called “‘onics and ‘tronics” tech boom of the late 1960s in America is one, the dotcom bubble on both sides of the Atlantic in the late 1990s another, and a rash of names with “blockchain” in them earlier this decade is perhaps the most recent example.
So is Newbird AI a harbinger of an imminent sticky end of the Artificial Intelligence boom, or even the stock market more widely?
Echoes of the past
It could be that this is no more than the latest over-heated meme stock frenzy, which will flame out, or at least cool down, in the same way as prior episodes involving GameStop, AMC Entertainment and non-fungible tokens.
A fresh retreat in the share price of Allbirds (as it is currently still known) leaves it with a stock market valuation of barely US$75m even now, and volatility in micro-cap stocks is hardly a new development.
Nor is changing a company name new. In many cases, the reasons behind a new moniker are perfectly sensible, as is the case just last week at micro-cap consumer goods specialist Creightons, which is renaming itself Potter & Moore in a nod to its founders and thus the company’s heritage.
But in others, the new identity, especially if coupled with a new strategy, can be an attempt to polish a damaged reputation, cover up more serious flaws or simply pump a share price and sell it to the unwary.
There is nothing illegal about any of this, and investors can make up their own mind about Allbirds. But this instance has strategists on edge for the echoes of the past that it provides – especially when other, softer indicators are already starting to gently flash amber, if not red.
Wash, rinse, repeat
Classic, late-cycle developments can include a rash of new stock market initial public offerings (IPOs) and then follow-on share sales by management or early-stage backers, especially if a certain industry or sector is in favour with investors and valuations are lofty.
Besides name strategy changes to jump on the very same bandwagon, other trends to note can be surges in new investment funds which specialise in fashionable market areas; rocketing share prices for investment banks and brokerages as share trading volumes surge; and increased use of derivatives and trading on margin, with borrowed money, as fear of missing out takes over and traders and investors look to maximise returns, almost irrespective of risk.
The putative IPOs of Space X, Chat GPT-owner Open AI and Anthropic will be one test, especially if they spawn imitators or their backers look to sell more stock as soon as lock-ups expire.
The ongoing growth of margin debt in the US is another, as is the increased use of zero-day options and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) which offer two, three, four or even five times the daily price movement of the underlying security they are tracking.
But even allowing for how Allbirds briefly took flight, it is difficult to argue that all these features are evident. Perhaps it is too late by the time they are obvious and the market will already be correcting by then. Investors should at least be wary of taking more risk than they normally would, especially if others start piling in.
Bear in mind legendary investor Warren Buffett’s maxim: “The less prudence with which others conduct their affairs, the greater the prudence with which we should conduct our own affairs.”